Intel, Google announce mobile partnership for Atom Android smartphonesIntel and Google have announced a partnership to enable the use of Android software on Intel's Atom mobile x86-compatible processors, in hopes the chips can wrestle market share from the ARM processor family now dominating mobile devices.
According to a report by Reuters, the two companies "will work together to optimize future versions of Google's Android mobile software for Intel's Atom processors, hoping to speed the development and time-to-market of future Intel-powered smartphones."
The vast majority of smartphones, not to mention tablets and other mobile devices, use processors based on the ARM architecture and built by companies including Texas Instruments and Samsung.
Intel's troubled history of pushing Atom
Intel launched its Moblin (Mobile Linux) initiative in 2007 aimed at putting its Atom chips in netbooks running Linux. Microsoft then pushed its PC partners to use Windows XP rather than Linux for netbooks, a win for Intel because Microsoft's Windows platform only runs on x86 processors like Intel's Atom and not ARM. However, netbooks as a PC segment have since seen market growth collapse.
Intel has not been happy with Microsoft's efforts to support Atom however, complaining early last year that "Microsoft hasn't been quite as aggressive as we might have hoped at supporting Atom, especially in the embedded space and that's why we came up with our platform Moblin," in the words of Intel's James Reinders.
At the time, Intel had just announced a partnership to merge Moblin with Nokia's Maemo, resulting in a project called MeeGo. Reinders told Tech Radar at that time that "the progress of Windows 7 still limited - it doesn't go all the places we think Atom will go," and suggested that Android and iOS weren't as powerful as Intel wanted to see either. "We feel people want an operating system that is more powerful on these devices. Pushing Moblin is definitely about getting more choice it that space."
Intel demonstrated an Atom-based MeeGo tablet prototype concept last summer, and Nokia ultimately shipped two MeeGo devices, the N900 Internet Tablet (similar to an iPod touch, with smartphone calling features), and the N9 smartphone. Early this year however, Nokia disbanded its MeeGo team, limited release of the new N9, and announced a partnership with Microsoft to focus on Windows Phone 7 devices. Currently, Microsoft's latest smartphone platform exclusively targets ARM chips.
With Apple, Microsoft, Nokia and RIM all committed to ARM, Intel has limited options for pushing Atom on mobile devices; Android appears to be the only viable platform remaining to target. Intel hasn't announced any vendors that will actually use its Atom chips to power Android-based smartphones, but it hopes that Atom based smartphones could reach the market by early next year.
Partnering with Google gives Intel the credibility to suggest that Atom chips are plausible components for smartphone makers. Google itself expects to soon own Motorola Mobility, giving it the power to release new versions of Android exclusively on its own Atom hardware with a first to market advantage, if Intel were actually able to deliver a hardware advantage to using its Atom chips in mobile devices.
Apple picks ARM over Atom
Apple was a cofounder of the original ARM mobile architecture in the early 90s, and used early versions in its Newton MessagePads. It then returned to ARM chips in building the iPod in 2001. In an early design phase of the iPad, however, Apple examined Intel's new Atom line, then called Silverthorne.
The primary benefit of Intel's Atom chips is backward compatibility with its desktop line of x86 processors, like those used in both Apple's Macs and in Windows PCs. Apple's Mac OS X was designed to be largely processor agnostic however, enabling the company to deliver an ARM version of its OS for mobile devices under the brand iOS.
Apple ultimately decided that Atom wasn't efficient enough to run the iPad, and instead developed its own new ARM chip design it branded A4. That chip was also used to power iPhone 4. Apple subsequently developed an A5 successor for use in iPad 2, and is rumored to be evaluating ARM processor designs for use in future highly mobile Macs, where efficiency may be more valuable than performance.
While Apple aggressively moved its Mac platform to Intel in 2006 and has since demonstrated unique applications of Intel chips in systems ranging from the Mac Pro to the Mac mini to the MacBook Air, Intel has worked to find alternative hardware vendors capable of building everything from mini PCs to "ultralight" notebooks to the Atom-based tablet Apple opted not to build.
Apple actively removed support for Atom processors in Mac OS X 10.6.2, making its operating system software unable to work on other makers' Atom-based netbooks. Last year, Apple also shifted its Apple TV product from a low powered Intel chip to ARM in order to help make the device smaller, cheaper and run cooler.
Microsoft has also announced efforts to make portions of its Windows 8 run on ARM chips sometime next year, enabling its software to run on more efficient hardware than Intel can currently deliver.
This summer, a report indicated Intel was interested in building future Apple-designed ARM chips, which may allow Apple to transition its CPU fabrication business away from Samsung.
At the same time, Intel's chief executive Paul Otellini told reporters after the announcement that "the smartphone business is not established in terms of the ultimate shake-out of who's going to win and who is going to lose.
"You saw what happened in terms of how fast Android took share from Apple," he said, suggesting that Apple had lost market share to Android in smartphones, something that is not the case.
On Topic: Intel
- After eating AMD & Nvidia's mobile lunch, Apple Inc could next devour their desktop GPU business
- After eating Intel's mobile lunch, Apple could next devour Qualcomm's Baseband Processor business
- How Intel lost the mobile chip business to Apple's Ax ARM Application Processors
- Intel CEO confident chipmaker can keep powering Apple's Macs by innovating
- Five barriers that might hold Apple back from moving Intel Macs to custom ARM chips