Monday, January 23, 2012, 06:23 pm PT (09:23 pm ET)
Inside Apple's efforts to expand iPad content with iBooks AuthorApple is seeking to democratize digital publishing on iPad using web standards, building upon technology it developed for Mac OS X Dashboard and iAd rather than delivering textbooks as native iOS apps.
Unlocking iPad for more content developers
With iBooks Author, Apple is attempting to do for ebooks what it previously did with music for iPods and mobile software for the iPhone: create a functional market for compelling digital content to drive iPad sales.
iPad already has compelling content in the form of more than 140,000 apps specifically optimized for it. However, creating these apps requires specialized Cocoa programming skills. iBooks Author enables non-programmers to create dynamic content for iPad without any software development experience.
Developers prefer native apps
In 2007, Apple's developers were not impressed when the company unveiled its initial web apps strategy for third party development. Programmers knew they could achieve a lot more by writing native Cocoa apps, just as Apple had.
Apple subsequently announced it would make native iOS apps possible early the next year with an iPhone SDK, paired with the new App Store to help developers market them. That SDK allowed Mac programmers to use the Xcode development tools they were already familiar with to create new iOS apps.
The other advantage to native apps over web apps is that Apple only sells native apps within its App Store. That gives them an edge in marketing, discoverability and profitability. While web apps should be able to run on any mobile device, they lack a good business model and are harder to monetize.
Apple likes web standards
For a number of reasons, Apple prefers using web standards to Cocoa in some situations, ranging from Dashboard widgets to iAd content to iTunes Extras (below) to the iTunes Store presentation itself.
One reason is simplicity, another is security. It's much easier to keep Dashboard widgets or iAds from introducing potential security vulnerabilities if they're implemented using web standards and contained in a web sandbox.
However, Apple has never delivered any easy to use tools for creating iOS widgets or other content based on web technologies. The company has created technical instructions that explain how experienced web developers can develop content for iTunes Extras and iTunes LP, which are aimed at Apple TV and can be sold through iTunes.
iBooks as web content
Push Pop Press, founded by two Apple engineers, went the opposite route, aiming to deliver dynamic ebooks implemented as native iOS apps. This enabled the company to craft far more sophisticated multitouch titles than the relatively plain ebooks one could create for iBooks 1.x, which implemented EPUB 2.0.
The company abruptly left the ebooks market after being acquired by Facebook last fall, with rumors first suggesting the company feared patent litigation from Apple. Push Pop cofounder Kimon Tsinteris subsequently told AppleInsider that the rumor was "factually inaccurate" and noted that Apple had awarded Push Pop Press an Apple Design Award.
Commentator John Gruber reported he had heard from a "well-informed little birdie" that Steve Jobs had "more or less warned Push Pop Press that Apple was going in the same direction," similar to a warning Jobs gave Panic developers after they expressed an idea for building a digital photo management program prior to the release of iPhoto.
"Yeah. Don't do that one," Jobs reportedly told them.
Push Pop Press developers haven't clarified whether they abandoned the idea of 'ebooks as apps' due to direct competition from Apple that they had somehow failed to anticipate, or if they decided that native apps were the wrong way to deliver ebooks, or if they failed to find much interest among conventional publishers, or if they simply found a more interesting role at Facebook.
iBooks Author's narrow target
Whatever the reason for Push Pop Press' abrupt departure from the market, Apple's own entry into ebooks with iBooks Author and iBooks 2 does not broadly seek to cover the needs of all publishers. Instead, it only targets textbooks, and initially those aimed at primary schools. Other ebook publishers, notably Amazon, have far wider aspirations.
While distantly behind Amazon in ebooks, Apple's advantage is tied to iPad, which is quickly being adopted by schools as a low cost, high value personal computer that children readily relate to. Amazon hasn't made much progress in pushing its Kindle readers into schools, and its mainstream models are targeted towards novel readers, not textbook-sized interactive tablets that can support 3D models and multitouch navigation.
With its natural advantage in education, Apple is attempting to induce the production of new dynamic content that will help sell iPads. Rather than expecting publishers to embrace Xcode development and produce digital textbooks as native iPad apps, the company has produced a tool that makes generating dynamic iBooks as easy as laying out Keynote presentations.
That's not necessarily giving Apple the best start, and segment two indicates: Initial iBook 2 titles offer disappointing interactivity
On Topic: iTunes
- Apple fills out iTunes Festival lineup, deadmau5 to kick off event
- Apple expands Volume Purchase Program to 16 new countries in education, business push
- Apple adds 21 acts to iTunes Festival card including Lenny Kravitz, The Script and more
- Apple remembers Robin Williams with iTunes tribute page
- Apple adds Family Sharing support information to iOS, Mac App Store listings