As noted by Bloomberg, investment bank MDB Capital Group, which specializes in intellectual property, issued the estimate for Kodak's digital-imaging patent collection, calling the company "the lowest hanging fruit out there." The firm's CEO, Chris Marlett, told the publication that Kodakâs patents âcould go for a huge number and nobodyâs talking about it.â
Kodak's market capitalization, the total value of its outstanding stock, stood at $575.77 million on Tuesday, less than one-fifth of MDB Capital's $3 billion estimate for just one segment of the company's patents. The company has tumbled sharply from a prior market value of $30 billion after being left behind in the digital era.
Fund manager Walter Todd said the company "âmissed the boat with the transition to digital," though its intellectual property is valuable. "This whole patent area has become really hot," he said.
The Rochester, N.Y., company is currently in the process of suing Apple over a digital imaging patent that could be worth as much as $1 billion in licensing royalties. When asserted against South Korean electronics giants Samsung and LG, the patent brought Kodak more than $950 million in royalty revenue.
Though Apple won some early victories in Kodak's case against it with the International Trade Commission, the final ruling on the case has been cast into uncertainty. Earlier this month, the chief administrative law judge at the ITC retired, just weeks before he was to issue a final judgment on the case. The ITC has said the case will be reassigned to a new judge.
Interest in patents has reached a fever pitch, culminating in Google surprising market watchers by announcing a $12.5 billion deal to acquire Motorola Mobility on Monday. Analysts viewed the move as largely a patent play, as Google has found its Android mobile operating system under attack from infringement claims by rivals Microsoft and Apple. If the deal is approved by regulatory officials, Google will gain 17,000 issued patents and 7,500 in-process patent applications. The company also recently purchased a group of patents from IBM.
"I think that we've seen some very aggressive licensing demands in the Android ecosystem," Google Chief Legal Officer David Drummond said. "And we think that having the patent portfolio will make sure that Android is open and vibrant, and the kind of platform that lots of companies can remain on."
In June, Apple and several other of Google's competitors, including Microsoft, Research in Motion and Sony, beat out Google in a bidding war over a group of 6,000 patents from bankrupt Canadian telecom equipment maker Nortel. The consortium paid $4.5 billion for Nortel's patent collection.
Kodak began shopping its 1,100 digital-imaging patents around in response to the high interest in the Nortel auction. After hemorrhaging $2.5 billion in losses since 2005, the struggling company is desperate for cash. So desperate, in fact, that the company is said to be considering the sale of the valuable image preview patent it has accused Apple of infringing on.
"Given the heightened demand in the marketplace for premium intellectual property assets, we believe that the timing is right and that we have a great opportunity for these very valuable assets," Kodak Chief Executive Antonio Perez said last month.
25 Comments
Here we go. It doesn't matter what your company does, but what patents it holds to sell to the highest bidder.
Not sure I like the direction where this is going...
What? Kodak is struggling?
Must be because everybody is using digital photography now, and most of it is done on mobile phones, eliminating the market for traditional cameras, which was Kodak's main staple. Kodak always struggled to compete in the digital camera arena, but their film and disposable cameras are still the most popular and widely used on the market.
But, in this age, very few people are using film anymore (you can thank Facebook, Flickr, etc for this), and Film is a dying medium. It is the film photography market that Kodak still is King, but there is not "much" to be King of in this area, compared to the whole "photography realm" where Digital is now king.
Begun, the patent wars have....
Begun, the patent wars have....
Post of the week.
What? Kodak is struggling?
Must be because everybody is using digital photography now, and most of it is done on mobile phones, eliminating the market for traditional cameras, which was Kodak's main staple. Kodak always struggled to compete in the digital camera arena, but their film and disposable cameras are still the most popular and widely used on the market.
But, in this age, very few people are using film anymore (you can thank Facebook, Flickr, etc for this), and Film is a dying medium. It is the film photography market that Kodak still is King, but there is not "much" to be King of in this area, compared to the whole "photography realm" where Digital is now king.
You mistake (faulty) reasoning for fact. Kodak was the early leader in digital imaging - consumer cameras, professional cameras, sensor technology, scanners, and printers. That's why they have such a strong patent portfolio. An incompetent management team killed their digital business.