Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Apple, Google anti-poaching class action suit to proceed after court refuses appeal

Steve Jobs and Eric Schmidt during the iPhone's introduction at MacWorld in 2007

Last updated

Apple, Google, Intel and other big-name tech companies will face a class action lawsuit over alleged anti-poaching measures after an appellate court refused to hear an appeal of a 2013 class certification order.


The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals handed down its ruling on Tuesday, denying a petition from defendants for permission to appeal a district court order that granted over 64,000 workers class certification, reports Reuters.

As a group, the plaintiffs are accusing Apple, Google, Adobe, Intel and others of an "overarching conspiracy" to keep employee pay down through anti-poaching agreements.

"We look forward to seeking justice for the class at trial," said Kelly Dermody, co-lead counsel for the class.

In April of 2013, District Court Judge Koh denied class status to the plaintiffs, noting workers did not show adequate show harm from the alleged illegal recruitment methods. The jurist reversed her initial decision in October after the presentation of information gathered as part of normal pretrial proceedings.

Court filings note that defendants allegedly implemented a variety of anti-poaching methods, including "do not call" lists, personal emails and other correspondence. Named in the allegations is late Apple cofounder Steve Jobs, who in 2007 sent an email to then-Google chief Eric Schmidt, asking him to stop poaching Apple employees. Schmidt acquiesced to the request.

In their petition to appeal, defendants in the case argued that worker background was too diverse to be considered cohesive. According to court documents, employees held over 2,400 job titles ranging from software and hardware engineers to animators and digital artists.

Dermody said Apple and its codefendants will meet again in court when the trial begins on May 27.



21 Comments

cnocbui 17 Years · 3612 comments

This has nothing to do with patents, it's to do with companies conspiring to keep down the salaries of their most important employees while the upper echelons of the companies reward themselves with annual remunerations of over $50 M a head.

appleinsiderfrm 11 Years · 120 comments

[quote name="MacHarry de" url="/t/161584/apple-google-anti-poaching-class-action-suit-to-proceed-after-court-refuses-appeal/0_100#post_2458000"]BORING, all this patent crap[/quote] LOL, I don't read the articles either.

macharry de 11 Years · 126 comments

Yeah, I know - It's not about patents in this case but the never ending war ... also boring ;-)

gatorguy 13 Years · 24627 comments

Glad to see this proceeding. Absolutely the wrong thing to have done IMO.