Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Japanese court says Apple's iPhones, iPads don't infringe on Samsung patents

Apple has once again defeated rival Samsung in the courtroom, this time in Japan, where it was ruled that the iPhone 4S, iPhone 4 and iPad 2 do not infringe on data communication patents owned by the South Korean electronics giant.

The decision was handed down on Tuesday by Tokyo District Court Judge Koji Hasegawa, who ruled that Apple will not have to pay damages to Samsung Electronics, because its devices do not infringe on Samsung's patents. In response, Samsung issued a statement to Bloomberg saying it was "disappointed" by the decision.

"Upon a thorough review of the ruling, we will determine which measures to take, including an appeal," the company said.

Apple and Samsung have been at odds in courtrooms across the globe for years, with each accusing the other of patent infringement. So far it's been Apple who's found the most success, having been awarded more than $900 million in one U.S. trial alone after successfully proving that Samsung had copied the patented designs of the iPhone and iPad for its own competing devices.

In Japan, court cases between Apple and Samsung date back to 2011, with each having sued the other for alleged patent infringement. Both sides have earned victories over one another, though Apple may have scored the most significant victory last June, when a Tokyo court found that Samsung had infringed on the iPhone maker's "rubber banding" or "bounce back" patent.



21 Comments

SpamSandwich 19 Years · 32917 comments

Hooray for lawsuits! (I'm only half kidding)

❄️
MacPro 18 Years · 19845 comments

It always hits me that in all this dislike of Scamsung, at the end of the day, when handed a total iOS rip off by Google, their designs inevitably had to be pretty similar to an iPhone. The evil is really Google, and always has been.

🎁
sudonym 10 Years · 233 comments

How can Samsung claim copyrite when all they ever do is copy Apple?  They should make Samsung pay for all of Apple's lawyers! Just look at the picture of Samsung before the iPhone and Samsung after the iPhone.  It is very clear who the copycat is here and Apple did nothing wrong.

 

Samsung should be punished for this.

❄️
darklite 11 Years · 229 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by SpamSandwich 

Hooray for lawsuits! (I'm only half kidding)

It'll just go to another appeal. The only winners here are Samsung and Apple's legal teams.