Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Foxconn's Wisconsin deal riskier for taxpayers than originally thought

Apple CEO Tim Cook visiting a Foxconn facility in China

Last updated

Foxconn's upcoming $10 billion display factory in Wisconsin is more lucrative to the Apple supplier than first thought, with state and municipal sweeteners adding almost an extra $1 billion in benefits above an existing incentive package worth $3 billion, increasing the burden on taxpayers.

As part of the deal to open the 20 million-square-foot facility in Wisconsin, a package of $764 million in incentives has been provided by Mount Pleasant and Racine County, the town and county where it will be built, reports the Wall Street Journal. On top of this, the state of Wisconsin pledged another $134 million for the improvement of state highways and local roads near the site.

The latest benefits are in addition to existing financial incentives, which primarily consists of $2.85 billion in income tax credits for job creation and capital expenditures. There is also a sales tax exemption worth $150 million as part of the $3 billion bundle.

The state will be responsible for covering 40 percent of the public bonds used to finance all of the local expenses, in the event the project fails completely.

In return for the incentives, Wisconsin will be the venue for the major LCD panel factory, which will create 13,000 jobs in the state over a number of years. The increase in employment could also be beneficial for areas near the facility, including local businesses seeing increased trade and changes in house prices.

While originally believed to produce large display panels, it is thought the facility could end up producing small and medium-sized panels due to the transportation risks associated with bigger screens. Considering Foxconn is a production partner for Apple products, and is the owner of iPhone and iPad display producer Sharp, it is plausible that some future iPhone screens could be produced from the Wisconsin facility in the future.

In May, one report made the claim that iPhone screens would be sourced from the Wisconsin facility, but the issues with shipping US-produced components overseas for assembly could be too much of a liability for the project.

Apple does perform limited manufacturing in the United States, such as assembling its current Mac Pro in facilities in Texas. As there is no indication that assembly of products with sizable screens like MacBooks or iMac models will take place in the U.S. anytime soon, there seems to be little prospect of Wisconsin-produced screens being used for US-based Apple product assembly in the future,

The company will break ground in southeastern Wisconsin on Thursday.



57 Comments

mbmoore 6 Years · 12 comments

How can there be a larger burden on taxpayers than they have already? Is Foxconn getting a pay out in addition to their exemptions? Not sure I follow the logic here. They will be employing thousands of people in different capacities, who will all be paying taxes.

Mike Wuerthele 8 Years · 6906 comments

mbmoore said:
How can there be a larger burden on taxpayers than they have already? Is Foxconn getting a pay out in addition to their exemptions? Not sure I follow the logic here. They will be employing thousands of people in different capacities, who will all be paying taxes.

Did you read the article? It doesn't seem like it.

In short, these are new incentives for Foxconn, above and beyond what the state pitched. The costs to the state are continuing to climb.

gatorguy 13 Years · 24627 comments

It's being reported that the tax concessions cost per projected Foxconn plant job is an astounding 231K... and that was BEFORE this latest disclosure. If accurate that's plainly a ridiculously one-sided agreement. Is this what "winning" looks like to taxpayers?

 The state will be paying for 30% of Foxconn’s total investment in the plant
 $1.5 billion in state income tax credits for jobs created
 $1.35 billion in credits for capital investment
 $150 million in sales tax exemptions on construction materials.
 Foxconn will pay no corporate taxes on profits from sales on products made here so costing the state about $200 million a year....

 and now another "$764 million in incentives has been provided by Mount Pleasant and Racine County" and "$134 million for the improvement of state highways and local roads near the site."
 ... but they can get back a chunk of it with personal income taxes on working people over the next 15-50 years. What a grand idea!

nunzy 6 Years · 662 comments

This will this will probably lower Apples cost and thereby increase their profits. That way, more money goes to Wall Street where it can be invested productively.

racerhomie3 7 Years · 1264 comments

Meanwhile ‘Medicaid for all’ will be any better for the taxpayers . That ship (fiscal responsibility)has sailed long ago. At least new jobs are being made. I am happy.