Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Apple requests another $179 million in supplemental damages from Samsung

Last updated

Three weeks after finally receiving $548,176,477 from Samsung over the South Korean company's infringement of Apple's design and technology patents dating back to a 2012 jury verdict, the iPhone maker has filed for another $178,659,870 in supplemental damages and $1,192,490 in interest payments.


The supplemental damages and interest come on top of the the original $548 million Samsung finally agreed to pay earlier this month.

The supplemental damages, compiled on Apple's behalf by CPA Julie Davis, relate to continued infringement by Samsung after the original jury verdict of willful infringement was first issued in August 2012, continuing through this spring, when Apple filed its motion for supplemental damages.

The figure is based on unit sales figures provided by Samsung of five infringing models (quite old Galaxy S II variants) that Samsung continued to sell after the verdict was reached over three years ago.

If Apple is awarded the full amount, it will bring Samsung's total payout for infringement to less than $750 million, far less than the profits it made over the past four years by studying Apple's designs and then documenting its process of "slavishly copying" them as closely as possible, despite being fully aware that those designs and technologies were ostensibly protected by patent law.

While failing to win its initial demands in a series of cases brought to U.S. courts, Apple has effectively crushed Samsung's infringement-based profiteering in the market place, delivering a series of high end products that customers have selected in preference to Samsung's, even when the latter offered major price discounts and free offers. While failing to win its initial demands in a series of cases brought to U.S. courts, Apple has effectively crushed Samsung's infringement-based profiteering in the market place

While Samsung has seen its phone and tablet profits implode over the past year, Apple reported September quarter profits of $11.1 billion, twice that of Samsung Mobile at peak-Galaxy and five times what it is now earning.

Over the last year, Apple's sales of iPhone 6 models have crushed every other flagship Android or Windows phone, allowing the company to gobble up 94 percent of all profits earned in the smartphone industry, despite having equal (or inferior) access to markets, carriers and distribution.

Samsung is now producing record numbers of low end phones, and is set to be among those most impacted by future predictions of slowing global demand for smartphones. Additionally, Apple has also cultivated a highly profitable iPad business and launched a new Apple Watch that has in its first year become far more successful than all of Samsung's various Gear watches sold over the past three years.

While Samsung and Apple remain each other's largest partners, with Samsung supplying vast numbers of components and providing large scale chip production for Apple, the company is expected to lose Apple's A10 chip production next year to TSMC. Apple is also appears to be continuing to explore alternative suppliers and vertical integration in ways that will devastate the steady business Samsung has relied upon for many years.



35 Comments

badmonk 11 Years · 1336 comments

DED, Thanks for this update & keeping the Christmas candle fire burning (on Samsung's ass).

lkrupp 19 Years · 10521 comments

The pictures contained in this article say it all. End of story.

proline 11 Years · 223 comments

This is a great way to add some insult to injury. An even greater insult is that Apple destroyed Samsung on the open market- while Sammy's smartphone profits were but a fleeting dream, customers keep going back to Apple again and again, paying $500-$800 each time. Hardly anyone these days will pay even $400 for a Samsung phone.

macky the macky 15 Years · 4801 comments

FYI, there is some editing that needs to be done to this paragraph:

While failing to win its initial demands in a series of cases brought to U.S. courts, Apple has effectively crushed Samsung's infringement-based profiteering in the market place, delivering a series of high end products that customers have selected in preference to Samsung's, even when the latter offered major price discounts and free offers. While failing to win its initial demands in a series of cases brought to U.S. courts, Apple has effectively crushed Samsung's infringement-based profiteering in the market place 

Merry Christmas, Spam! Did you just finally notice DED's signature writing style: "Never delete a phrase that works, even if you find two or three more ways to say it."

With that, I want to send out PC Holiday Wishes to the AI staff and especially DED, stay the course!!

I'm looking forward to seeing what Apple drops on the market on 2016 that no one is/was expecting. Along with Sog, I'm looking forward to Apple stock hitting 150 and even soaring past... This coming year Apple's alliance with IBM will hit its stride while Microsoft will suffer another management crisis and revert back to Uncle Fester's vision of losing market share to Apple and "anything but Windows" OS's. 2016, the year Apple wins the hearts and minds of the world market so powerfully that the TIME magazine "Man of the year" will feature Jon Ive, and the "deal of the year" will be Apple buying Samsung's chip division after starving it's production of all Apple's business. At the close of 2016 Apple's string of victories that both Sog and the WSJ, along with financial pundits will all be singing the praises of Apple's management and Apple's future...