Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Nokia, Apple courtroom showdown to wait until mid-2012

The legal battle over mobile technology patents between handset makers Apple and Nokia will likely drag out for years, with both companies looking for a court hearing to be held in 2012.

The trial date with the U.S. International Trade Commission was revealed in a court filing obtained by Reuters this week. It noted that the date raises "the spectre of a prolonged legal struggle."

When the battle between the two giant companies began last fall with Nokia suing Apple over alleged patent violations, some said if Apple countersued, the battle between the two Goliaths could last two or three years. Sure enough, only months later, Apple filed a countersuit against Nokia, accusing the Finnish company of its own list of patent infringements.

In January, the ITC agreed to investigate Apple over the complaints lodged by Nokia. Weeks later, the U.S. commission announced it would also investigate Nokia over Apple's claims.

Reuters noted that Apple originally accused Nokia of infringing 13 patents the Cupertino, Calif., company owns. However, the suit has since been revised to remove four from the list.

Analyst Gene Munster with Piper Jaffray has said he believes Nokia seeks a 1 percent to 2 percent royalty on every iPhone sold. That would amount to about $6 to $12 per handset in compensation for intellectual properties related go GSM, 3G and Wi-Fi.

While Nokia first provoked Apple with a lawsuit last fall, Apple recently began its own patent-related pursuit against handset maker HTC earlier this month. The iPhone maker filed a suit with the ITC accusing HTC of infringing on 20 patents related to the handset's user interface, underlying architecture and hardware. Some believe the lawsuit is meant as an indirect attack against Google's Android mobile operating system.

The ITC has been busy with Apple lately. The U.S. commission is also investigating a complaint from camera maker Kodak, which has accused Apple of infringing on patents related to the previewing of images and processing them at different resolutions. Kodak believes Apple's iPhone infringes on those inventions.



17 Comments

igenius 15 Years · 1240 comments

It is truly sad when companies rip off other's technology instead of innovating.

ascii 19 Years · 5930 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by iGenius

It is truly sad when companies rip off other's technology instead of innovating.

I know, right? Jeez guys, fight it out in the marketplace like real men.

anantksundaram 18 Years · 20391 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by AppleInsider

The legal battle over mobile technology patents between handset makers Apple and Nokia will likely drag out for years, with both companies looking for a court hearing to be held in 2012.

Nothing unusual about this. Standard fare. These things take years, and in 2015, we'll all go "what the heck was this all about, and who cares!"

igenius 15 Years · 1240 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by anantksundaram

Nothing unusual about this. Standard fare. These things take years, and in 2015, we'll all go "what the heck was this all about, and who cares!"

That is a huge problem when litigating tech patents. By the time there's a decision, the tech is too often obsolete.

finetunes 14 Years · 2057 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by anantksundaram

Nothing unusual about this. Standard fare. These things take years, and in 2015, we'll all go "what the heck was this all about, and who cares!"

Unless you believe that that the world is going to end in 2012.

Yeh, these things take years and cost $$$$$$.