Josh OngGreg Sandoval of CNET reported Tuesday that a rollout of longer iTunes samples may have been blocked by the National Music Publishers Association. In an earlier report published just days before Apple's Sept. 1 event, Sandoval predicted Apple would bump iTunes song samples from 30 seconds to 60 seconds, but the announcement failed to materialize at the event.
According to Sandoval, Apple's agreements with just the four major record companies to provide longer song samples weren't enough. When both the NMPA's general counsel and chief executive learned of Apple's plan by reading CNET's report, they contacted the Cupertino, Calif., company with their objections.
"We believe that a license is necessary, and conversations must occur before song samples are extended," NMPA general counsel Jay Rosenthal told CNET last Wednesday.
Several publishers have felt that they're not getting their fair share from iTunes, as they believe Apple should pay performance rights for song samples. Apple had countered with the argument that a 30-second sample is promotional, but its push for longer samples has reopened the debate.
Hanna Pantle, a spokeswoman for BMI, which collects royalties for songwriters and publishers, said the organization is currently in "active negotiations" with Apple about the length of song samples.
Music industry insiders say Apple "tried to rush a deal through" without securing agreements from all the necessary parties.
As the "number one music community in the world" with over 160 million users in 23 countries, iTunes certainly has leverage with the labels and publishers. But, it may face stiffer competition this fall as Google readies its own online music store.
Charles Martin
Christine McKee
Wesley Hilliard
Malcolm Owen
Andrew Orr
William Gallagher
Sponsored Content
27 Comments
Music publishers are stupid.
They're probably (pointlessly) worried about people ripping it off for ringtones or something like that, I suppose.
What a sad joke of an industry. In a few more years, these guys/gals will be all gone. Finished.
In a few more years, these guys/gals will be all gone. Finished.
Really?
Just where are they going?
Do you ever have any knowledge about the topics you're posting on?
Or do you just reflexively post anything that pops into your head?
Before Apple purchased and subsequently shuddered Lala.com the full length song previews were in use by me almost every day. I bought more music because of it. Even better (for all parties involved) I bought more of the music I knew I would like and keep because it was so easy to listen to the whole album first, making me less gun shy about buying even more music, if you follow.
Bring on the longer samples, music publishers. It's really a no-brainer. 30 second song preview is like a movie trailer--a tiny sampling and what you actually get could be quite different when you see (listen to) the whole thing.
It does seem the issuing of "rights" appears to boil down to who you are, not what you want the rights for. It's annoying me that iTunes users are getting punished because of this.