Roger Fingas
Looking to deflect allegations, T-Mobile denied that it's throttling YouTube for users of its Binge On perk, instead saying that it's presenting "mobile optimized" content.
"Using the term 'throttle' is misleading," a representative explained to DSL Reports. "We aren't slowing down YouTube or any other site. In fact, because video is optimized for mobile devices, streaming from these sites should be just as fast, if not faster than before. A better phrase is 'mobile optimized' or a less flattering 'downgraded' is also accurate."
Last week YouTube complained to the Wall Street Journal that T-Mobile was degrading its video to 480p resolution, even though it isn't a Binge On partner. In exchange for sub-HD video, Binge On allows people to watch video from services like Netflix and HBO without it counting against their data caps.
"Reducing data charges can be good for users, but it doesn't justify throttling all video services, especially without explicit user consent," a YouTube spokesman said at the time.
T-Mobile blamed the problem on the software it uses to flag videos as exempt from caps, which is apparently poor at recognizing YouTube content. The two companies are reportedly working on solving the flaw.
The point could eventually be moot, as the U.S. Federal Communications Commission has expressed worries that things like Binge On may violate net neutrality rules. Services participating in Binge On could be said to have preferential treatment of their traffic, putting other services at a disadvantage.
Charles Martin
Malcolm Owen
William Gallagher
Christine McKee
Wesley Hilliard
Andrew Orr
7 Comments
Yeah, iPhones used to do this with the old Apple-bundled Youtube app when AT&T was the only carrier, and we were still in the 3G era. Using youtube's Mobile web page fixed that, generally.
Quite surprised that it's coming from T-Mobile, however.
so are youtube videos exempt from data and from tethering? If they are downgrading it the answer should be yes. I hope this is the case as the value of tmobile would skyrocket in my mind: apple music, netflix, and youtube tether free and data free.
As a very happy T-Mobile user, and a formerly annoyed Sprint user, I can't say I have had ANY problems whatsoever with the service I've been getting when watching YouTube using data on my phone. It works perfectly, looks great, and is very, very fast.
Looking to deflect allegations...
deflect allegations...
allegations...
Allegations gonna eat yo dawg.
Throttling is slowing down data, we've all heard it before used by carriers. What T-Mobile is doing is not throttling. What I don't like is how YouTube specifically prohibits the user to manually change the quality of a streaming video while on a cellular network, either as an embedded video in Safari, or in their YouTube app. So, I for one, am very happy about T-Mobile intervening to provide an optimized experience.