Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

FBI Director James Comey seeks to reassure Congress that Apple fight is not about precedent

The Federal Bureau of Investigation does not believe its battle with Apple will result in a legal precedent that could weaken encryption protections across the board if the bureau prevails, director James Comey told the House Intelligence Committee on Thursday.

Comey said that the case is "unlikely to be a trailblazer," according to Reuters. Apple has taken the opposite position, with chief executive Tim Cook going so far as to call the court order the "software equivalent of cancer."

During his testimony, Comey did acknowledge that any decision handed down in the California matter would be "instructive for other courts" — perhaps a worrying conceit, given that the bureau is seeking similar orders in at least nine other cases.

Still, that is not the agency's goal, Comey told the panel.

Instead, the debate over encryption — which he called the "hardest question I've seen in government" — is "really about who do we want to be as a country and how do we want to govern ourselves," he said.



29 Comments

thewhitefalcon 11 Years · 4444 comments

Breaking: FBI director is a blatant liar.

16 Likes · 0 Dislikes
bloggerblog 17 Years · 2530 comments

Precedence will happen wether it was intended or not. If this case goes to court and the FBI wins, next time a similar situation occurs or if the FBI wished to trample on someone's rights, the victory will be used as precedence 

7 Likes · 0 Dislikes
anantksundaram 19 Years · 20391 comments

How does this guy say this with a straight face? Isn't there some enforceable law against lying to Congress?

10 Likes · 0 Dislikes
smaceslin 15 Years · 86 comments

FBI:  Really.  You can trust us.  We'd never lie.  Really. Ha! B)

6 Likes · 0 Dislikes
kent909 16 Years · 730 comments

How does this guy say this with a straight face? Isn't there some enforceable law against lying to Congress?

He is not lying. He really believes what he is saying. Trust me when I say they cannot help themselves. There are parts of their brain that just do not function. It is a disability not a choice.

8 Likes · 0 Dislikes