A family in British Columbia has demanded Apple pay it $600,000 to help cover uninsured losses endured from a farmhouse fire in October 2016, one claimed to have been started by an overheating cable used to charge an iPhone 6.
Cathy and Ian Finley of Langley, B.C. were forced to close their farm business after the late-2016 house fire, which they blame on the cable and the three-month-old iPhone 6, which was left charging in their living room, reports CBC. Cathy Finley advises it was charging unattended, as she plugged it in before leaving the building to feed goats, later spotting the house on fire.
On arriving back to the house, the fire was too large to get neat to the structure, forcing Mrs. Finley to go to a neighbor for assistance.
There has yet to be an official determination for what caused the fire, but officials investigating the blaze found the iPhone charger and cable in the building's remains. A report from the investigators states "it would appear that the phone or charger generated enough heat to ignite" a chair at the point of ignition.
The farm business previously provided sustainable farming tours and hosted kids camps, as well as providing food and other services to the local community. Following the fire, the family claim they were too overwhelmed to continue operating their vegetable delivery program, refunding customers who could not be provided the service, as well as cancelling plans for celebrity chef dinners and school tours.
The family started to build a new home on the site in August 2017, but despite working to dig trenches and divert power and water, Mrs. Finley worries there are not enough financial resources to complete the construction. "We might lose this house that we are building with our own hands," she suggests.
So far, the family has received an insurance payout of $600,000, but this reportedly did not cover all costs. It is claimed the uninsured losses, including loss of revenue from the farm and tour business, building costs, and mediation, total another $600,000, which the family wants Apple to pay.
Mrs. Finley started to ask Apple for help since February 2017, but says she has failed to get anywhere with the company after multiple conversations with Apple's case worker. The Finleys claim that an adversarial relationship has erupted between the insurers, The Co-operators, and Apple regarding the incident, with Apple refusing to engage further until it gets an opportunity to examine the iPhone and charging gear that is currently being held by a third-party forensics company.
After a year of communicating directly with Apple and not getting a result, the family has since turned to taking Apple to task in public to try and get a satisfactory result. The attention-getting methods include a Change.org petition that is said to have hit 1,700 signatures within a few days of launch, and at the time of publication has exceeded 2,300 signees, as well as some interest from Facebook users.
Apple has yet to publicly comment on the affair, but did confirm to the CBC that it was looking into the couple's situation.
39 Comments
Why is there no official determination of the cause of the fire? Why is Apple not afforded an opportunity to examine the phone and charging gear? Is that not reasonable before they would assume responsibility?
Without a doubt, Apple should offer a free cable. They should not have their customer continue to use bogus 3rd party cables. If they don't let Apple see it, one might assume that's the case.
Until the cause of fire is determined then no-one, including Apple are liable for a single dollar. Aside from that, is it possible the family did not have adequate insurance cover seeing as they also ran the home as a business and the pay-out seemingly only met HALF of what it's costing to put right.
edit* this article states the cause of fire is as yet undetermined, yet the family claim to have a fire report explicitly blaming the iphone left on charge? hmmm
"The Co-operators, and Apple regarding the incident, with Apple refusing to engage further until it gets an opportunity to examine the iPhone and charging gear that is currently being held by a third-party forensics company."
OMG, how incredibly unreasonable! Apple should just write them a check. Who are they to ask to see the evidence that they are at fault? /s
I’m glad to see sane people posting today. Apple is not “yet” to blaim or the bad guy here. I wouldn’t pay a single cent either, without seeing the item, or even an official cause of the fire.
Is it physically possible for the charger to cause a huge blaze and look like it's not singed or melted?
Edit: ah, I suppose the theory is that the charger sent too much power to the phone and the phone overheated not that the charger itself overheated. That seems plausible.