Apple's AR plans include accurate handling of real and virtual objects

Future Augmented and Virtual Reality systems and updates to ARKit from Apple could display virtual objects alongside real ones, and also allow for the manipulation of them both. The difficulty so far has been in assessing when the user is actually touching such an object, or is merely very close to doing so.

A new patent application from Apple, "Depth-based touch detection," US Patent No 10,572,072, details the problems inherent in exclusively using virtual camera positions to calculate whether a touch has occurred.

"Using cameras for touch detection [does have] many advantages over methods that rely on sensors embedded in a surface," says the patent. It describes Face ID-like systems where "vision sensors [or] depth cameras" provide a measurement of distance between the lens and the touch surface.

"[However, one] approach requires a fixed depth camera setup and cannot be applied to dynamic scenes," it continues. Another approach works by identifying the user's finger then marking surrounding pixels until so many are recorded that effectively the finger must be touching the surface. "However... this approach... can be quite error prone."

These existing systems rely on what Apple calls "predefined thresholds," calculated points where a touch is assumed or not. "They also suffer from large hover distances (i.e., a touch may be indicated when the finger hovers 10 millimeters or less above the surface; thereby introducing a large number of false-positive touch detections)," it continues.

While not trying to replace these systems, Apple's patent application describes also using depth detection. "[A] measure of the object's "distance" is made relative to the surface and not the camera(s) thereby providing some measure of invariance with respect to camera pose," says the patent.

Apple's system would first identify an object such as "a finger, a stylus or some other optically opaque object." Next, it would identify the "planar or non-planar" surface.

This detection would continue as the user moves, and this gives the system a series of readings over time, or what Apple refers to as a "temporal sequence of outputs."

The purpose of the system is to detect touch where there may not be anything on the surface material to react to that contact. "Computer functionality can be improved by enabling such computing devices or systems to use arbitrary surfaces (e.g., a tabletop or other surface) from which to get input instead of conventional keyboards and/or pointer devices (e.g., a mouse or stylus)," says the patent.

"Computer system functionality can be further improved by eliminating the need for conventional input devices; giving a user the freedom to use the computer system in arbitrary environments," it continues.

The patent is credited to two inventors, Lejing Wang and Daniel Kurz. Between them, they have around 60 patents, which include many related ones such as "Method and system for determining a pose of camera," and "Augmented virtual display."

This patent follows many AR and VR ones from Apple, most recently including one utilizing fingertip and face mapping tools to also help with touch and interaction.