Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Power button Touch ID on the iPad Air 4 was an 'incredible feat'

The power button on the iPad Air 4 now houses the Touch ID sensor.

Last updated

A pair of Apple executives have discussed changes to the iPad introduced in the iPad Air 4, including the "incredible feat of engineering" to add a Touch ID sensor to the power button on the new model.

Apple revealed its iPad Air 4 on September 15, complete with an updated A14 Bionic chip, a design inspired by the iPad Pro line, and a larger 10.9-inch display. Arguably the biggest departure for the iPad Air is its biometric alterations, with Touch ID moved from the now-gone Home button to the power button on the top.

Speaking on the iJustine and Jenna Ezarik podcast Same Brain published on Saturday, Apple VP of hardware engineering John Ternus and Apple VP of product marketing Bob Borchers talked about the changes that the iPad lineup underwent during the September event.

On the subject of Touch ID on the tablet, Borchers described the change as "an incredible feat of engineering to get that fingerprint sensor with all of the capability and all of the security into that form factor."

When asked if the power button Touch ID was using the same technology as the original but in a smaller form factor, Ternus suggested it was more an "evolution of the technology" employed by the system. "We wanted to get to the full-screen design and so we wanted to get rid of the Home button on the chin, and so we had to come up with another place for the Touch ID sensor."

"What made it so challenging is this really narrow aspect ratio that it has," Ternus offered, due to being on the top of a slimline button. "If you think about it, it's only ever seeing a smaller slice of your fingerprint than what a traditional, you know, what our older sensor could do."

Ternus continued "it has to be incredibly sensitive and it also has to capture as you go through the enrollment process and then as it continues to adapt over time, a broader view of the fingerprints. So no matter how you touch it with your finger, it's got that particular portion captured and so it can do the match."

A "lot of algorithm work, a lot of hardcore silicon" was put into practice to create "such a capable sensor in such a tiny little space," but one that Borchers pointed out was "a really sophisticated space" due to the other items in the region that have to be managed while introducing a new sensor.

"On the cellular iPads, the top portion of the enclosure is the antenna," Ternus explained, which meant they had to place "this incredibly sensitive Touch ID sensor right inside an incredibly sensitive antenna, and had to figure out how to make them work with each other and not be talking over each other and causing interference."

"As these products become more feature rich, and obviously more compact and condensed, it's becoming more and more critical that our teams are collaborating really, really tightly together," he continued, "because the Touch ID team and the antenna team had to be in lockstep through the entire engineering process."

Apple's design for a power button Touch ID sensor may find its way into more products in the future. One day before the iPad Air 4's launch, analyst Ming-Chi Kuo forecasted that more iPad models that lack Face ID will adopt the change in 2021.



45 Comments

Chris_Saul 4 comments · 4 Years

Stretches credibility since it’s not like Apple is the first to have this capability

hmlongco 586 comments · 9 Years

Stretches credibility since it’s not like Apple is the first to have this capability

I suspect that once more it's a case of Apple taking a feature and actually doing it right....

https://beebom.com/galaxy-a7-power-button-fingerprint-scanner-face-unlock/

red oak 1104 comments · 13 Years

It is the incredible thought and execution on things that largely get taken for granted that makes Apple such a special company 

Apple's iPad lineup is amazing 

elijahg 2842 comments · 18 Years

hmlongco said:
Stretches credibility since it’s not like Apple is the first to have this capability
I suspect that once more it's a case of Apple taking a feature and actually doing it right....

https://beebom.com/galaxy-a7-power-button-fingerprint-scanner-face-unlock/

Well Sony had it in Q4 2015 (except in the US, because Apple had patented a fingerprint reader in a power button in Q2 2015) and it is as fast as the one on the then current 6S. So really, Sony beat them to the punch by 4 years, which also means this is 4 year old tech that Apple is touting as an "incredible feat". That said, I have no idea how secure the Sony one is comparatively. The touch sensors are essentially ultra-high resolution CMOS-based touchscreens, high enough resolution to capture the ridges of your fingerprint in detail high with enough resolution to authenticate. 

Also:

"On the cellular iPads, the top portion of the enclosure is the antenna," Ternus explained, which meant they had to place "this incredibly sensitive Touch ID sensor right inside an incredibly sensitive antenna, and had to figure out how to make them work with each other and not be talking over each other and causing interference."

Surely a simple solution is turn off the RF for a few hundred milliseconds while the fingerprint snapshot is taken, as to not affect the sensor, which wouldn't drop the cellular connections as they're easily robust enough to lose several seconds of data. 

This all sounds like a lot of marketing bluster to me. 

retrogusto 1140 comments · 16 Years

I’m not sure how much data transfer I’d want my iPad to be doing while it’s locked anyway. Maybe I’m missing something, but it seems like most of the operations where you wouldn’t want a split-second of interference would take place when you’re actively using the iPad in its unlocked state. But just because a few other highly advanced tech companies have accomplished something similar doesn’t mean that it isn’t difficult to achieve.