Mike Wuerthele
Another Chinese national has been sentenced his role in a scheme to defraud Apple out of more than $1 million with counterfeit iPhones.
The latest defendant in a million-dollar fraud scheme has been sentenced. Teang Liu is the latest to see jail and big fines over his role in the scheme.
The scheme involved receiving shipments of counterfeit clones from Hong Kong that had spoofed IMEI and serial numbers corresponding to authentic Apple devices. Liu, together with other conspirators, would then return these inauthentic devices to Apple, claiming that they were legitimate devices still under warranty. The goal was to receive authentic iPhone devices as replacements.
Those authentic replacements models were then shipped back to conspirators overseas, including in Hong Kong.
Liu was recruited by the already-sentenced Haiteng Wu to take part in the scheme. In addition to the conspiracy itself, Wu and Liu also secured fake identification documents, opened multiple commercial mail receiving mailboxes, and arranged for members of the scheme to travel through the U.S.
In total, Apple was hit for over $1 million. The conspirators were arrested in December 2019.
Liu pled guilty in February 2021. Judge Emmet G. Sullivan sentenced Liu to a year and a day in prison $577,780 in restitution, and a $57,780 forfeiture judgement.
The case was investigated by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, Homeland Security Investigations, and the U.S. Postal Inspection Service.
Charles Martin
Amber Neely
Sponsored Content
AppleInsider Staff
Malcolm Owen
Oliver Haslam
10 Comments
How is paying the $577,780 restitution enforced? Is this one of those situations where it looks good on paper but will actually never happen?
Years ago a neighbor of mine resisted arrest, ran from the cops and was tackled onto the hood of my car. The hood was scratched up pretty badly. My neighbor was deemed the responsible party and ordered to pay for the repair. He had less money than he needed to get by, was constantly leaning on others and I never got a dime.
This scheme seems to be a lot of work for not that much “reward”. A little over a million but you have multiple people involved, lots of shipping, international travel, etc. I would guess a lot of expense involved in generating that million.