Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Multi-touch patent settlement with Elan costs Apple $5 million

Apple has reached a settlement in a multi-touch patent infringement suit with Elan Microelectronics Corp., in which the iPhone maker will pay out $5 million.

Taiwan-based Elan will also share patents with Apple as part of the settlement, Reuters reported on Thursday. The settlement stems from a lawsuit filed by Elan against Apple in 2009, accusing the company of violating two patents related to multi-touch input, and Apple counter-sued the same year.

Apple's relatively small payout for a company with billions of dollars in cash reserves comes months after the U.S. International Trade Commission ruled that Apple did not infringe on an Elan patent. Elan had accused Apple of "knowingly and deliberately" infringing on its technology for products like the iPhone, trackpads and the Magic Mouse.

Elan Microelectronics was founded in 1994 and builds integrated circuits used on touchpads. Its products include "eFinger," which allows for multi-finger input with handwriting recognition.

The $5 million settlement means Apple has one less lawsuit on its docket in an industry filled with patent infringement claims among device makers. Notable companies involved in patent infringement litigation with Apple include Samsung, HTC, Motorola and Kodak.



22 Comments

tallest skil 15 Years · 43086 comments

I'm sorry, so why did Apple pay them if they weren't infringing?

simtub 15 Years · 277 comments

Why isn't Elan suing every other manufacturer that makes multitouch smartphones and tablets?

geoffrobinson 15 Years · 54 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tallest Skil

I'm sorry, so why did Apple pay them if they weren't infringing?

Lots of times people and companies settle because it is cheaper than defending oneself. Lawyers = money.

$5 million is a rounding error for Apple.

tallest skil 15 Years · 43086 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by simtub

Why isn't Elan suing every other manufacturer that makes multitouch smartphones and tablets?

Because the other guys aren't the ones making money.

gatorguy 14 Years · 24646 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by Tallest Skil

I'm sorry, so why did Apple pay them if they weren't infringing?

The ITC's opinion was that they weren't infringing. Elan had also filed a companion suit in Federal Court making much the same claim. Apple might have lost that one, so settled rather than take a chance.

At least Apple doesn't have to steal Elan's IP anymore.

/s