Following a five-year run in Detroit that saw him inexplicably chosen to oversee General Motors, longtime telecom executive Dan Akerson has elected to weigh on in Apple's possible entry into the carmaking arena, saying that Cupertino has "no idea what they're getting into."
"I think somebody is kind of trying to cough up a hairball here," Akerson told Bloomberg. "If I were an Apple shareholder, I wouldn't be very happy. I would be highly suspect of the long-term prospect of getting into a low-margin, heavy-manufacturing business."
GM's gross margin for the fourth quarter of 2014 was just over 11 percent — compared to nearly 40 percent for Apple - but Akerson was even more harsh in his assessment of Apple's manufacturing expertise.
"[Apple] better think carefully if they want to get into the hard-core manufacturing," he added. "We take steel, raw steel, and turn it into car. They have no idea what they're getting into if they get into that."
Akerson's comments are somewhat bizarre, given Apple's reputation for diving deeply into the development of materials and processes used to manufacture its devices. The forthcoming Apple Watch Sport, for example, uses ion-strengthened glass thought to have been developed in-house.
GM is no longer a vertically-integrated company, either. Much of the "raw steel" the automaker turns "into car" is supplied by European materials giant ArcelorMittal.
The auto industry has been aflutter since rumors of an "iCar" began to gather steam earlier this month. Apple was outed as the operator of a fleet of sensor-laden minivans that have been crisscrossing the country in recent months, a finding which sparked two separate reports of an early-stage Apple vehicle development program.
Apple spun up a "top secret research lab" for the project last year, the Financial Times said, kicking off the free-for-all. Design czar Jony Ive is believed to have personally recruited automotive executives, and the company is known to have offered massive bonuses and substantial pay raises to employees of electric carmaker Tesla.
The Wall Street Journal weighed in later, claiming that Apple CEO Tim Cook gave the go-ahead for iPod and iPhone designer Steve Zadesky to assemble as many as 1,000 workers to make an electric car. Zadesky's group is though to be researching "robotics, metals and materials consistent with automobile manufacturing."
143 Comments
Yeah, I'm sure the telecom industry said the same thing when Apple decided to make a phone in-house.
A couple points to comment on...first, are we 100% sure Apple is getting into this full tilt? Second has this guy seen what Apple has done with every segment they go into? They turn low margin, average industries into high margin lucrative ones...when you see a guy like this make comments that are so off mark it boggles my mind that they make it into upper management of large corporations...
I suspect this is a dashboard play and/or a foray into self driving vehicles. For some strange reason I feel a Mobileye acquisition in the wings. I note in the previous AI story Tim Cook is headed to Israel. Hmm, how convenient!
He looks a little bit, and sounds a little bit, like Ballmer mocking the iPhone way back...
I still don't think Apple is building a car. Maybe some systems for one but not an iAuto.
That being said, this guy comes across like that idiot CEO at Blackberry when the iPhone was introduced. Whatever Apple does, I'm sure it will be pie in this guy's face.