Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Google's reluctance to add privacy labels to Gmail, other apps might put users at risk [u]

Last updated

Google has taken so long to update its popular Gmail app for iOS that a new in-app warning informs users that the title is "out of date" and does not include the latest security features.

The search giant in early January said it would update its entire iOS app suite with new Apple-mandated privacy "nutrition" labels, but many titles under the company's umbrella have yet to be revised.

As noted by MacRumors, Gmail is now warning users that the app does not include built-in safeguards and cautions against its use. The app was last updated more than two months ago on Dec. 1.

"You should update this app. The version you're using doesn't include the latest security features to keep you protected. Only continue if you understand this," the pop-up reads.

The alert appears upon initial setup or when adding a new account, and users who are already signed in will not see the message.

Google's delayed action is thought to be in response to Apple's new privacy label feature that rolled out in December. Dubbed privacy "nutrition labels," the program is designed to supply users with new levels of app transparency by requiring developers to provide insight into how their apps leverage user data.

For example, developers must divulge what data is being collected by either itself or a third party, and how that information might be used. Similar to past App Store policies, apps are allowed to remain on the storefront without publishing the privacy labels, though the new rules will be enforced when updates are submitted.

Previous reports suggested Google would delay rollout of future updates to avoid exposure of its data collection strategies, but the search giant denied those allegations. A spokesperson for the company in January said it is not fighting Apple's policy and plans to publish updates with privacy labels "soon."

While Google has added the required information to some of its apps, like YouTube, others including Gmail, Google Photos and Google Maps have been left untouched for months.

Update: Google appears to have updated its Gmail backend to remove the warning as it no longer appears when configuring a new account.



23 Comments

badmonk 1336 comments · 11 Years

I am sure GatorGuy will be around shortly to explain why this is not a concern.

StrangeDays 12980 comments · 8 Years

I’m confused, why is their own app issuing this warning? I don’t use it, but I assume that’s server-side generated web content rendered in the app?

bulk001 795 comments · 16 Years

I’m confused, why is their own app issuing this warning? I don’t use it, but I assume that’s server-side generated web content rendered in the app?

They probably don’t want users to know that they are compromising their privacy  - for instance, maybe scanning emails to feed you ads or selling your private data gleaned from emails to third parties. What else would make them delay updating this information? I use the app every day BTW but don’t have any personal information that would concern me if it was publically revealed! :smile: 

crowley 10431 comments · 15 Years

I’m confused, why is their own app issuing this warning? I don’t use it, but I assume that’s server-side generated web content rendered in the app?

I'd guess that some new feature has been implemented server side, and also checks whether the client supports it.  The Android app has likely been updated so that this message doesn't appear, but the iOS app is lagging for whatever reason.

anantksundaram 20391 comments · 18 Years

I honestly do not understand this story.  But I have no doubt better minds do. 

So, what does responding to Google’s warning (and updating) actually do?!