Will Shanklin
A new study reveals that 60% of apps used by schools share data with third parties, with iOS sharing less than Android, and as a rule, to less "risky" aggregators.
The research comes from Me2B Alliance, a non-profit group describing itself as "focused on respectful technology."
The study found that Android apps were three times more likely to share data with third parties. Of the 44 apps found sharing student data, 73% were Android apps. Android apps were also much more likely to send data to third parties labeled either "high risk" or "very high risk."
The research says 91% of Android apps send data to "high-risk" parties compared to 26% of iOS apps. 20% of Android apps sent data to "very high-risk" parties, compared to only 2.6% of iOS apps.
On average, each school app transmitted data to more than ten third-party data channels. The third parties the apps sent data to included advertising platforms like Google and Facebook.
Data typically included unique identifiers that allow ad trackers and other third parties to build tracking profiles for students. The profiling practice includes children under the age of 13.
The study adds that most of the apps initiated data transmission as soon as the app loads. This finding means that they begin tracking the student even before they've signed in to the app.
The Me2B Alliance tested a random sample of 73 apps used by 38 schools across 14 different U.S. states. The team conducting the tests says the audited apps cover more than half a million users, including students, their families, and educators.
"The findings from our research show the pervasiveness of data sharing with high-risk entities and the amount of people whose data could be compromised due to schools' lack of resources," said Lisa LeVasseur, executive director of Me2B Alliance. "The study aims to bring these concerns to light to ensure the right funding support and protections are in place to safeguard our most vulnerable citizens - our children."
Andrew Orr
Amber Neely
William Gallagher
Christine McKee
AppleInsider Staff
7 Comments
As I have posted several times, people give lip service to privacy and security but in practice they don’t care one bit. Most of Apple’s efforts in this matter go unappreciated and ignored. If people cared iOS would have a much larger marketshare, which it doesn’t. Ipso facto privacy is not important.
Collecting and aggregating data from children, especially preteens in a captive scenario like a classroom, seems like it would be far more than a privacy concern.
Disgusting. I'd be pissed to find out my child's info was being mined for the purpose of Google and Facebook to profit off of. ATT needs to expand and become the norm, not the exception.