Mike Peterson
A Texas man is seeking a class action suit against Apple for allegedly selling defective batteries and violating its warranty promises after his iPhone exploded in his face in 2019.
The lawsuit, lodged Thursday in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, claims that the iPhone 6's battery "contains a defect which makes it unable to reliably perform its function." It goes on to allege that the defect "creates a danger of explosion and fire."
According to the complaint, plaintiff Robert Franklin of Hopkins County, Texas had his iPhone 6 device explode in August 2019. "Robert Franklin was listening to music on his iPhone 6, when he noticed the music playing on his iPhone began to skip," the lawsuit reads. "As he picked up his iPhone to investigate, [it] suddenly exploded and caught fire in his face."
The complaint goes on to say that the plaintiff suffered injuries to his eyes and wrist as a result of the incident. The latter injury occurred because the fire caused him to fall, during which Franklin used his hand to brace himself.
"With a defective battery, Plaintiff's iPhone 6 was unsafe to operate and was destroyed by the explosion," the complaint says.
The plaintiff reportedly suffered economic loss because of the incident. Costs included those to replace the iPhone, plus medical treatment for his injuries.
According to the lawsuit, Apple is in violation of Texas law because it sold a un-merchantable product. It alleges that Apple's warranty, which claims that the iPhone 6 would be free from defects, turned out to be untrue.
Exploding iPhones are rare, and normally occur because of user-caused damage to a device after it has been sold. There is no rash of exploding iPhone batteries now, or in 2019, when the plaintiff's battery burst. Lithium-ion battery liquid is flammable, and damage to a device containing a battery can cause the battery to swell, rupture, or otherwise fail.
The iPhone 6 was first sold in 2015, and the plaintiff reportedly purchased his in 2018 — about a year before the incident occurred. It isn't clear what condition the phone was in prior to the explosion, where he bought the device, or if he bought it new or used.
The lawsuit seeks class action status and a jury trial. It asks for damages for the allegedly defective iPhone 6 and its battery, incidental damages for replacement devices, and attorneys' fees and court costs.
Franklin v Apple by Mikey Campbell
Stay on top of all Apple news right from your HomePod. Say, "Hey, Siri, play AppleInsider," and you'll get latest AppleInsider Podcast. Or ask your HomePod mini for "AppleInsider Daily" instead and you'll hear a fast update direct from our news team. And, if you're interested in Apple-centric home automation, say "Hey, Siri, play HomeKit Insider," and you'll be listening to our newest specialized podcast in moments.
-m.jpg)
William Gallagher
Andrew Orr
Christine McKee
Andrew O'Hara
Malcolm Owen
19 Comments
Was it plugged in? If so, was he using a reputable adapter? So many questions.
He bought the iPhone 6 in 2018? Probably not new or referb. Considering how rare battery explosions are rare, I don’t see class action.
Probably would have happened if Apple had not taken heat for extending the life of batteries by throttling to detect conditions that causes spiking in old failing batteries. Cant win for loosing.
Feel bad for Apple, everybody just like to sue Apple for every little thing. But when the same thing happened to other company they don’t get sued like Apple does for some reason. Battery explosion is hard to come bye, if that is the case, they will have to do some investigation like what lead to it.