Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Samsung drops injunction applications against Apple in 5 European countries

Samsung announced on Tuesday it will drop patent injunction applications filed against Apple in five different European countries, though a number of lawsuits alleging patent infringement remain.

A senior executive with the South Korean electronics maker told The Wall Street Journal that injunction applications filed in the U.K., France, Germany, Italy and the Netherlands will all be pulled from court. The injunction cases were related to wireless telecommunications technology, but Samsung noted that lawsuits filed in Europe related to patent infringement remain active.

The withdrawn applications are a major shift in the war between Apple and Samsung, where court filings and disputes have piled up in dozens of countries around the world. Samsung's withdrawal of injunction applications was "unilateral and voluntary," and the company declined to say whether they came as a result of out-of-court talks with Apple.

"Samsung remains committed to licensing our technologies on fair, reasonable and nondiscriminatory terms, and we strongly believe it is better when companies compete fairly in the marketplace, rather than in court," the company said in a statement. "In this spirit, Samsung has decided to withdraw our injunction requests against Apple on the basis of our standard-essential patents pending in European courts, in the interest of protecting consumer choice."

Samsung's announcement comes quickly after Apple was denied a motion in the U.S. for permanent injunctions against Samsung devices found to have infringed on certain design and utility patents. Samsung, meanwhile, was also denied a motion from Judge Lucy Koh for retrial on the basis of alleged jury misconduct.

So far, Apple has had the most success in its patent infringement accusations against Samsung. Most significantly, Apple was awarded $1.05 billion by a jury in California.

In the U.K, Apple was forced to post a notice on its website declaring publicly that Samsung did not copy the design of the iPad. The court ordered Apple to post the statement after it lost a patent infringement complaint against Samsung.



9 Comments

lkrupp 20 Years · 10521 comments

Hopefully something is going on behind the scenes between Apple and Samsung but I kind of doubt it.

tbell 18 Years · 3145 comments

No this likely has to do with the EU investigating Samsung and Motorola's over their attempts to use FRAND patents to gain injunctions.

irnchriz 18 Years · 1595 comments

[quote name="TBell" url="/t/155083/samsung-drops-injunction-applications-against-apple-in-5-european-countries#post_2248383"]No this likely has to do with the EU investigating Samsung and Motorola's over their attempts to use FRAND patents to gain injunctions. [/quote] This ^^ Sounds far more likely, that and their Lawyers probably think that they wont win due to appearing to 'double dip' on licensing fees.

charlituna 17 Years · 7217 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by TBell 

No this likely has to do with the EU investigating Samsung and Motorola's over their attempts to use FRAND patents to gain injunctions.

 

Yep. This is likely them trying avoid any further 'guilt' to pile onto the investigations, plus bad press. it is very easy to prove that Apple would be severely damaged by a loss of sales and if Samsung wins they can use the sales numbers to justify higher damages from the court (just as Apple would use the loss of sales to get treble awards etc if the injunction was granted). The courts are showing they aren't keen to give these injunctions anyway so why carry on and give more fuel to fires. 

spacepower 13 Years · 207 comments

So Samsung is going to stop using FRAND pledged SEPs to try to get injunctions. Good but they should have seen the error of their ways much earlier, since the EU, US, and South Korea are all looking into the matter. Maybe they realized that if they block the iPhone, they would have to start a whole new Galaxy marketing campaign? Ha Now let's see what Google/Moto decides to do, though they will probably wait until the ruling on the MS/Moto case.