Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Apple AirPower charging plate uses Qi protocol, but may not be compatible with other devices

Last updated

Apple's AirPower charging plate will charge three Qi devices, and appears to be the first plate that takes advantage of the protocol's ability to deal with multiple devices on the same charger by sensing the location of the device, and only inducing a charge in those locations.

At present, the most common Qi implementation allows for one device to be charged by one base station. As an example, the Belkin charging plate, announced on Tuesday, adheres strictly to that requirement.

There is no specific order for devices on the device, and it appears at this time that a Series 3 Apple Watch, the AirPods Wireless Charging Case, and a compatible iPhone can be placed nearly anywhere on the pad.

This is allowed implicitly by the Qi standard — it just appears that nobody else has done it the way that Apple is, just yet.

How Qi works

The Qi standard relies on induction between two coils to deliver power to a device that needs charging. The base station contains a transmitting coil that generates a oscillating magnetic field, which induces an alternating current in the receiving field.

The coils are aligned with each other in either guided positioning relying on the user to place a device in a specific position and alignment, or hardware can be built allowing for free positioning.

Free positioning is generally used in most charging plates, with relatively minor adjustments made by magnetic positioning or other mechanical apparatuses.

Other multiple device Qi charging pads like the Incipio Ghost 220 still have specific locations, and are using multiple coils in one charging unit.

Qi also allows for free positioning to be implemented by inducing a magnetic field just at the location of the receiving coil with multiple cooperative flux generators. Devices put on a plate communicate their location, and the field is only induced under the device by the flux generators operating in tandem.

Apple appears to be using this method for a trio of devices that can be placed in any order, on any location on the pad.

Pay it forward?

Apple is a member of the Wireless Power Consortium, and has been since February. It has been using an off-shoot of the Qi technology in the Apple Watch prior to the Series 3, albeit made proprietary by MFi-based authentication.

The Wireless Power Consortium trumpeted the release of the technology in the iPhone 8, iPhone X, and Series 3 Apple Watch. In a statement, an executive for the group claimed that Apple's inclusion is paving the way to "ubiquitous access to wireless charging."

Apple cognoscenti John Gruber seems to think that Apple will share the technology it is using with the AirPower with the Qi members — but there is no obligation for the company to do so.



21 Comments

beowulfschmidt 12 Years · 2361 comments

Have I just missed the charging rate and power consumption comparisons between this and the dedicated chargers, and what the tolerances are for cases, or have there been none?

Not that it's going to matter a great deal.  This is kind of a no-brainer for my wife and I when it becomes available, and we upgrade to the 8, or X, or whatever it is we decided on.  One mat on the headboard for both of our phones?  Sign me up.

sirlance99 11 Years · 1301 comments

Really what choice would they have? Qi has been out for years and many places, cars and furniture already have Qi in place. Nobody wants fragmentation in this space. 

lkrupp 19 Years · 10521 comments

Did not Apple say at the event that they were working with the WPC to make multi-device chargers work?

MplsP 8 Years · 4047 comments

Have I just missed the charging rate and power consumption comparisons between this and the dedicated chargers, and what the tolerances are for cases, or have there been none?

Yeah, I was wondering that, too. If the charge rate is hideously slow it makes it much less practical. CarPlay requires me to plug in my phone, so car charging isn't an issue for me, and I leave my phone propped up on my nightstand so I can easily see it to hit snooze in the morning, so I'll probably keep plugging mine in regardless.

Even if Qi has been out for a while, Apple (or another company) could still cause fragmentation by using nonstandard implementations. Microsoft used to do that all the time in the 90's. I hope this isn't the case - having a universal standard would allow much easier use in public spaces like airports and hotels. How nice would it be to be able to just throw your phone on the nightstand at a hotel? From the article, it sounds like Apple was working with the consortium, so hopefully a multiple-device mat will be part of a new standard. If you extend the theory, an airport could have a 10 foot long counter with one big mat, allowing people to place their phones anywhere on it.

Mike Wuerthele 8 Years · 6906 comments

Really what choice would they have? Qi has been out for years and many places, cars and furniture already have Qi in place. Nobody wants fragmentation in this space. 

Well, given that they used a nonstandard Qi in the Series 0 through 2 Apple Watch, they have many choices. The standard does allow for what Apple looks to be doing with the AirPower.


It's not up to Apple to be sure that other devices are compatible with their technologies that they develop.