Mike Wuerthele
Maybe you can get away with a single Wi-Fi basestation, if you have modest needs, but with the arrival of 4K media streaming, home network bandwidth demands are growing quickly. AppleInsider shares a few tips on how to build out your network, and points out some problems to avoid along the way.
At AppleInsider we get asked a lot about basic networking and router setup and location, with a sudden flare-up after Apple announced that the AirPort lineup was dead and gone. While there are entire fields of study and engineering devoted to networking, there's no need to hit the books to set up a network for less than 10 people.
There are some best practices and things to consider instead of just slapping another Wi-Fi router on a network, or extending the network another 20 feet with a cable and a switch. So, let's cover some basics if you're thinking about going beyond a single router covering your home or small office.
This article is just an overview for beginners looking beyond just plunking down a single wi-fi router, so if you're an old hand at it, feel free to share your wisdom (but not what you're selling) in the comments section. We're also not really talking about best hardware in this article for your build, as that can vary dramatically from situation to situation.
Because of the AirPort's discontinuation, AppleInsider will continue to look at third-party options for the gear.
Plan it out!
Even if you've had a network for a while, periodically, take a step back and make sure that it can do what you need it to do, and do it well.
As buildings are put up around you and they get populated with their own gear, you may develop wi-fi dead spots. Also, as your family shifts rooms, you may have a concentration of gear where there wasn't one before causing connectivity problems.
So, even if you've got a good setup, it could still get better. And, if you're starting from a single router and expanding, a prior plan of what you need is essential before you go shopping.
Wireless only?
If it's just you, plus maybe one or two other people in a small space, then one good 802.11ac Wi-Fi router is probably all you need.
Most home networking gear's signals propagates in a torus, and is attenuated by dense building materials like brick, or a steel support beam. So, if you're using one Wi-Fi router, set it up as centrally in the house as possible.
If the family has a common gathering area, this is an obvious place to put your router. But, the practicality of this may depend on what the ISP has arranged for you for a home penetration.
While placement is important in relation to the user, the wireless signal could also be improved by manually selecting the right channel — even if your routers claim to do it automatically. There are a few Wi-Fi survey apps for iOS and the Mac available on the app stores. Deciding which is right for you is left as an exercise for the reader.
Multiple base stations
If, like in most homes, your primary internet drop is in the basement somewhere or along one wall of the house, then two or more basestations on opposite ends of the house or office might not be a bad idea.
A possibility on your AirPorts and on third-party routers is extending range with the Wireless Distribution System (WDS) protocol. We've never been fans, because you're sharing wi-fi bandwidth between the routers or extenders. It can also be fussy across different manufacturers.
If you're having problems with wireless reception in a nook or cranny of your house, either use Mesh networking hardware with discrete radios for communication between basestations, or an Ethernet backhaul instead.
Mesh networks
In the last few years, mesh networking hardware has debuted. The most recent batch are designed to be plunked down in disparate areas of your house, with one connected to your cable modem or router provided by your ISP and the rest of the mesh routers connecting to that one.
Skip the first generations of mesh networking hardware. They generally weren't any better than WDS connections between older routers, and had a price premium to boot. This was all rectified as the technology matured, and nearly all of the new gear has a dedicated Wi-Fi radio just for communicating between base stations.
Individual setup depends on the manufacturer, but they are generally app-configured from an iPhone or iPad, and negotiate connections between base stations automatically.
AppleInsider has examined the Google Wifi, Linksys Velop dual-band, and higher-end three-band systems and have found them easy to set up, with little maintenance or tweaking required. At present, mesh networking technologies are not cross-compatible, but the EasyMesh standard might smooth that out in the not too distant future.
Ethernet backhaul
In multiple-device environments, even the newest, speediest Wi-Fi networks can get bogged down. While Wi-Fi devices claim "up to" speeds, in reality, they are almost never met and dependent on many factors for actual speed — including congestion.
The highest traffic devices can be taken out of this equation with an Ethernet network. A number of modern homes are being built with them in place. But, if you've got an older home, or rent, running cables through walls can be problematic.
Running Ethernet is easy, before the drywall goes on.When running Ethernet cabling, pick Cat 6 cabling for future-proofing, and use higher quality cable. Instead of snaking cables through existing walls, consider "up and over" by running a cable from a utility room in the basement up to the attic, and down into closets of a bedroom, behind a kitchen cabinet, or something similar. If you have a basement with an open ceiling, between joists is a nice option too.
But, while convenient, the whole house doesn't need to be wired in a hybrid wired/wireless network.
Properly done, the real-world speeds on Ethernet are second to none. It will allow you to isolate an Apple TV 4K to wired, freeing up the wireless network for less bandwidth-profound impacts.
Powerline networking
Powerline networking uses the existing electrical wiring in your house to carry a "wired" signal elsewhere in the home. They have come a long way since they were originally released, but there are still caveats.
As a general rule, you can only use two of them, connecting point-to-point. It is possible to connect more that two Powerline networking devices given the right manufacturer and hardware selection, but as it cuts into the already reduced bandwidth compared to Ethernet, it is probably better to stick to just two.
What you can do is connect a Powerline spur of your network from your router to a switch on the other end of the house, say, behind a television or similar. Then, everything connected to that television, be it an Apple TV, second Wi-Fi base station, game console, or what have you, can be on a wired connection back to the main router.
Or, if there's a particularly difficult run, use Powerline to hurdle two close walls without drilling a hole.
If you need to use PowerLine as a backbone so you don't have to run a cable through your attic or basement, don't cheap out. Get the fastest one you can afford, because if you're using it as a major conduit from one location to another, you want the fattest pipe possible.
The speed and quality of the signal varies greatly depending on the house's wiring and a few other factors. For example, if the adapters are plugged into completely separate electrical circuits in a home and having to go through the house's breaker box instead of on the same run, you'll see cut-back speeds. How much depends on how bad the connection is.
The technology can also be prone to electrical interference in a variety of ways, including poor quality wiring for the sockets and in some cases the turning on or off of large appliances, such as refrigerators and microwave ovens.
MOCA networking
If you own your home, a MOCA network is a possibility. This will use the coaxial cabling for existing cable TV service in your house as pre-run network cabling, similar to Powerline plugs. And yes, unless you have AT&T's cable, and never had any other, you're good to go, even with an existing service.
But, we've never had great success with this. The speed and quality of the connection depends a great deal on situations beyond most homeowner's control. Something as simple as a low-quality coaxial cable splitter in a wall somewhere, or old cabling can completely torpedo the whole affair.
Traffic isolation
The best home network can still crumple under load, but this can be mitigated somewhat. While the vast majority of the traffic comes from the router, the destinations can be a chokepoint, causing problems downstream.
When you're building out an Ethernet network, it shouldn't be a line of cabling and switches. A hub and spoke design is far better than a line.
Also, if you have a network attached storage (NAS) device on the network, consider where it should go. It's not always best to have it next to the router, even though that's a central location. If its being used for media streaming, it may better serve the intended audience closer on the network to the main streaming device.
The future
As video shifts to higher and higher resolutions, and to a streaming audience, more strain will be put not just upon the streaming companies, but on ISPs and home networks as well.
A single 4K HDR video can require about 8 megabytes per second to stream without buffering, and in our own testing we've seen peak traffic at 12 megabytes per second. Stack multiple streams up at once on the same LAN, and it can quickly bring an network to its knees.
It would be a shame if your network couldn't handle it.
-m.jpg)
Charles Martin
Malcolm Owen
William Gallagher
Christine McKee
Wesley Hilliard
33 Comments
One tip I picked up a while back is to always name 2.4 and 5 GHz networks identically with same pass word. That way modern devices from Apple seamlessly select either that is best suited and can flip between them should the need arise. the 2.4GHz signals may sound less impressive but they travel further and through more walls. Correct me if this is a dumb idea but it works very well on my LAN.
One of the first things I did besides throwing up a large Antenna as a cable cutter was to wire my house with Cat6. I ran the cable under my house as my attic was just not practical. I ran power to my Closet that is in the middle of my house, but to get power there, I had to cut out the ceiling, fish a power cable to that location because as I said, attic wasn't practical. I have a low slope roof. Can only move around part way in the middle. It's very claustrophobic. Once got the wire there, I patched it back up as you can do that easy enough with drywall.
So all my Network stuff I have in that closet. I have a 24 port switch. I have run Cat6 from there into all my rooms. Some have 2 cables running into the room, some have 4, or more. All going to keystones in the rooms where you can plug right in.
I always say, things that don't move, PLUG-IN, things that move around on Wifi. So Xbox or AppleTV, etc that sit there are Plugged in. iPhone, iPad, on Wifi. I have a single ASUS router in that closet that handles my whole house, along with my Cable Modem and NAS and other things. Your Wifi Router normally has a Ethernet Switch built into it. It may have 1 port or 4 ports. You can get simple Unmanaged switches for cheap. 7 ports or like me 24 ports, though I have since gotten a Managed Switch. For most home users, you don't need or want a managed switch. Get a switch, and all you have to do is run a Ethernet cable from your router switch into your new Unmanaged Switch. That's it, and you now have more ports depending on how large of a switch you get. You can run a single Ethernet cable into a room and then Plug a small 5 port Ethernet switch in that room and then plug all your devices into that and have a small Siwtch in all your rooms instead of a single Large switch. It's pretty simple.
There are a number of tricks you can do to wire your house. If you rent, generally you're out of luck. There are some ways to wire up and be hidden without making holes everywhere. Ethernet is just going to be faster and more reliable. Wired is just better that wireless. These days are you get more and more devices that work only on wifi because of Home control, like myself with a growing Homekit house, getting as much OFF of Wifi that you can is even more important.
If you own your own place and can get under under your house or in the attic. Running Ethernet wire is not that hard. Cutting a hole in the wall for a low voltage box, and connecting to keystones to pop into a wall plate is not hard at all. Fishing wires is not hard. Cost is pretty CHEAP. I got all I needed from Monoprice.com. I was under my house for a couple days running a bunch of Ethernet, COAX cable for the Antenna, and ground wire for a couple rooms as I wanted grounded power outlets. That as just getting wires from point A to point B. That was 5 years ago and I haven't had to touch it sense. I would like to run Ethernet out to the garage and to a POE switch where I can have a few outside POE IP camera's on the outside of my garage. That's a future project.
I have a home with thick concrete construction throughout (that is how they are here in Germany) so the signal attenuation is extreme. I have my ISP provided router that connects to a simple Ethernet distribution block in the basement with it's four WAN ports. This distribution block then has wires that go to various floors in the house for wired connections. In my home office and in my bedroom (two different floors) I have two AirPort Extremes that then have my iMac and various other stationary devices connected via a wired connection. On the main level, I have an Airport Express that has my AppleTV connected to its WAN port. This works very well and AirPort Utility makes the set up drop-dead simple. The only change in the future might possibly be to swap the Express for the Extreme (AC) in the bedroom, but right now the majority of the wireless traffic (iPad video watching) is done on the floor with the bedrooms. The main floor has the TV with the AppleTV connected via Ethernet, and so the majority of the wireless traffic there is general surfing and messaging and such. I do have a few Homekit accessories on that floor as well, but their traffic seems to be minimal. As the kids continue to grow (and then use their own devices) this usage pattern may shift, but I don't think so. The only real shift I can forsee might be with the addition of more Homekit things as that market continues to mature and I add to my set up.
Pretty good article. But one other that should be mentioned aside from Powerline Adapters is MoCA Networking. Just about every older home, condo, apartment, town house including modern homes has coax wiring. Running Ethernet cable in older homes can really be a challenge for people that have concrete construction floors or basements for running cable through the walls and floors. What is MoCA? it stands for “Multimedia over Coax”. In short Ethernet over existing Coax lines in your house, which can handle both internet and TV signal if needed over the coax line to every room in your place. MoCA can also fix Wireless Dead Zones in your house. It's very simple to hookup too, All you have to do is purchase a MoCA adapter that goes between your Cable Modem and Wireless Router or they now have Wireless Routers that you can purchase that has MoCA built right into it. Then All you need is a MoCA adapter in each room where there is a coax jack and you will have that internet available in that room, you can even go even further by plugging one in a 5 port switch which will give you even more Ethernet ports in that room for your Entertainment setup with your HDTV and your Apple TV or other electronics you have like your Apple computers. Aside from this the one thing you will want to purchase is a PoE MoCA filter which protects your place from someone else from connecting to your MoCA network from outside your place. PoE filters also prevent the cross-interference, but MoCA signals can still interfere if a neighbor does not also have a filter. Hardwired Ethernet is the best , but for people with older homes, MoCA is almost same as wired cable. Here's a couple good How to Video's on MoCA Networking. http://www.mocainyourhouse.com/ http://www.mocainyourhouse.com/moca-videos-lontv About MoCA Network Adapters and Products https://www.actiontec.com/moca/