Malcolm Owen
A jointly-produced filing between Apple and Epic in its ongoing "Fortnite" courtroom saga reveals issues with discovery on both sides ahead of a case management conference, with each claiming the other isn't providing the required documentation.
In the Joint Case Management Statement filed on Monday, in advance of the case management conference scheduled for October 19, Epic and Apple both have issues with how the other company is handling the discovery portion of the lawsuits. Each company accuses the other of being uncooperative in different ways.
In Epic's portion of the statement, it accuses Apple of failing to provide all of the documentation it needs, namely that Apple's list of custodians that documents are supplied about does not include two prominent figures in Apple's history. Of the six people listed, Epic spotted that none of them are co-founder and late CEO Steve Jobs and current CEO Tim Cook.
Furthermore, Epic also claims Apple "repeatedly relied" on the two men during the two previous motion hearings. However, Apple countered by saying it didn't rely on them, rather that it mentioned the two twice, referencing Tim Cook's statement to the US House of Representatives Judiciary Committee and "an AppleInsider article quoting Steve Jobs."
Apple also claims it has already provided Epic "with the 3.6 million documents" produced by Apple in its developer class action and consumer class action suits. Epic believes these documents should have been provided sooner.
On Epic's side, it has already made "an initial production of more than 16,000 pages form the files of Timothy Sweeney," the CEO of Epic. Apple counters by claiming Epic may have "cherry-picked" the documents that may "omit a significant amount of relevant materials."
Apple also claims Epic received a third-party discovery request before it formed its lawsuit against Apple. Epic was said to have told Apple "to just wait a bit," then filed the lawsuit before responding to the subpoena.
After Monday's case management conference, both sides have until January 6 2020 to file data for the trial, which is set to take place sometime in July 2021.
-m.jpg)
Wesley Hilliard
Andrew Orr
William Gallagher
Sponsored Content
Christine McKee
Thomas Sibilly
3 Comments
I wish people would understand this: Fortnite's iOS revenue is infinitesimally small versus their iOS Unreal revenue. Epic charges 5% of gross for Unreal usage, and with the majority of Apple Arcade games being Unreal - Unity a rather distant second - Apple's advertising PUBG to spite Epic has provided Epic with a fantastic cashflow.
DO NOT SUPPORT APPLE ARCADE. IT DIRECTLY SUPPORTS EPIC. They're in this together. The only people losing are the consumer.
Yeah… I don't think Apple is out on a quest to kill Epic here. They are protecting what is their's — the App Store and iOS.
Love seeing Apple replace the scumbags with others during the presentation. Hope Pandora and League of Legends aren't next to cry about Apple.
It's Evil Goliath pretending to be David Vs. Good Goliath.