Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Qualcomm's president says Apple iPhone modem saga will end soon — but that seems unlikely

Last updated

Qualcomm President Cristiano Amon believes that the legal battle with Apple over the iPhone modem could end in 2019, but if history — and Apple's remarks — are any indication, that's a long-shot.

Apple and Qualcomm's royalty payments fight is heading to the San Diego federal court on April 15, seemingly bringing to a close a disagreement between the tech titans that has taken place over the last two years. In the view of Cristiano Amon, the end is apparently in sight.

"We feel like we are probably near the end of this game - we have a lot of legal milestones approaching," Amon advised to Yahoo Finance. "We see 2019 as having events that will drive resolution one way or another."

Amon's comments are similar to those made by CEO Steve Mollenkopf on November 28, where he suggested the two are "on the doorstep of finding a resolution." Claiming the two communicate as companies, Mollenkopf further suggested Qualcomm would "love to work with Apple" on future products, including a 5G-equipped iPhone.

Apple responded to Mollenkopf's comments in court, with Apple attorney William Isaacson taking a moment during a recent hearing to stress no negotiations were happening "at any level," there hadn't been talks "in months," and that reports the firms were close to a settlement are "not true."

In early November, a source believed to be within Apple or a hired legal team advised to one report "There is absolutely no meaningful discussion taking place between us and Qualcomm, and there is no settlement in sight. We are gearing up for trial."

As for Amon's suggestion the legal action is "probably near the end," it is highly likely that whatever the result of April's trial, the two companies will continue to argue over the result for a considerable amount of time, appealing to have the potentially high judgements against them overturned. For comparison, Apple's first blockbuster trial with Samsung took over five years from filing to completion and the stakes are no smaller in the Apple versus Qualcomm matter.

To wit, Qualcomm will probably dispute being demanded to pay the $1 billion in royalties that Apple believes were withheld, and would fight any court-ordered reduction in royalties that Apple would need to pay for its components and technology usage.

Qualcomm's complaints against Apple include the iPhone producer attempting to pay less than the fair market value for standard-essential payments, wrongly inducing regulatory action in a number of jurisdictions, breach of contract, and more recently accusations of stolen trade secrets being provided to chip competitor Intel.

Ultimately, neither company wants to lose this battle.



14 Comments

Rayz2016 8 Years · 6957 comments

The trouble is that they haven’t had much luck anywhere else with similar cases. 

ksec 18 Years · 1502 comments

It is sad that even if they do settle in 2019, it is highly unlikely Qualcomm will be in iPhone until 2021.I think ultimately Apple *may* be doesn't want any chip from Qualcomm, but simply want to sign an agreement for patents where both company don't sue each other, and Apple Pay a flat price for all SEP.

Apple will then make their own Wireless Chip, which combines 802.11ax , 802.11ay, 4G, 5G and Bluetooth.  

TomE 8 Years · 174 comments

QCOM President is right - It will be settled soon and they wll be out of Apple's Hair (or chip business) for good.

rotateleftbyte 12 Years · 1630 comments

ksec said:
Apple will then make their own Wireless Chip, which combines 802.11ax , 802.11ay, 4G, 5G and Bluetooth.  
and if they do, they will walk right into a whole host of Patent lawsuits launched by the trolls.
Not the Nokia and the other major players but those outside that group. All the current modem makers are probably in a mutual don't sue each other situation but if apple (or anyone) who is not part of that cartel tries to usurp their dominance, then the lawyers will be out on force. There are literally tens of thousands of patents in this area. For most companies, it is not worth the trouble to sue each other but with an interloper?
All bets are off and if that interloper is Apple then they will want loadsamoney.

tmay 11 Years · 6456 comments

ksec said:
Apple will then make their own Wireless Chip, which combines 802.11ax , 802.11ay, 4G, 5G and Bluetooth.  
and if they do, they will walk right into a whole host of Patent lawsuits launched by the trolls.
Not the Nokia and the other major players but those outside that group. All the current modem makers are probably in a mutual don't sue each other situation but if apple (or anyone) who is not part of that cartel tries to usurp their dominance, then the lawyers will be out on force. There are literally tens of thousands of patents in this area. For most companies, it is not worth the trouble to sue each other but with an interloper?
All bets are off and if that interloper is Apple then they will want loadsamoney.

So it shall be, same as it ever was.