Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Huawei punishes staff with pay cuts for marketing tweet sent via iPhone

Chinese smartphone giant Huawei has issued harsh punishments to two of its staff in the aftermath of New Year's Day marketing tweet sent out with the label "via Twitter for iPhone."

Both of the workers have been demoted one rank and had their monthly salaries cut by 5,000 yuan, or about $728, according to an internal memo seen by Reuters. One person, the company's digital marketing director, will have his pay rank frozen for a year.

The memo indicated that an outsourced social media firm, Sapient, encountered "VPN problems" with a desktop it was using for publishing, so instead turned to an iPhone with a roaming SIM card to trigger the message at midnight on New Year's. Twitter is normally blocked in China, so a VPN (virtual private network) is a commonplace tool for reaching it.

The post — which read "Happy #2019" — was almost immediately deleted, but not before screenshots made their way to social networks like Weibo, where they were roundly mocked.

Huawei has had similar embarassments in the past. A notable example was when Israeli actress Gal Gadot, serving as a paid ambassador, promoted the Mate 10 Pro on Twitter but used her iPhone to do it.

The illusion of brand unity has become important at smartphone makers around the world, especially given the intense competition between iPhone and Android as platforms. In reality workers will often have devices from rival companies, even at Apple, though corporate leaders sometimes take measures to deter this.

Huawei likely has little to worry about in the near future, as Chinese iPhone sales were poor enough in the December quarter to trigger this week's guidance downgrade. That sent Apple shares plummeting, and prompted CEO Tim Cook to promise management would "take action" to put the company on the right course.



20 Comments

🎄
genovelle 16 Years · 1481 comments

Huawei likely has little to worry about in the near future, as Chinese iPhone sales were poor enough in the December quarter to trigger this week's guidance downgrade
Except that even with Apple’s current level sales in China the make all the profits in their phone market. 

🎄
StrangeDays 8 Years · 12988 comments

So staffers and not a PR firm. And punishment from the top. Not a great look for life in China...

❄️
SpamSandwich 19 Years · 32917 comments

So staffers and not a PR firm. And punishment from the top. Not a great look for life in China...

No, it is not a good look. Plus, any celebrity hawking Chinese government-owned company products is a fool, including Gal Gadot.

☕️
radarthekat 12 Years · 3904 comments

First, the fact they could ‘turn to an iPhone...’ is all
that’s needed to be said.  What was an iPhone doing there?  Obviously, someone on staff prefers it over the brand they are representing in their job.  So that deserves a good laugh at the expense of Huawei.

Beyond that, the company has now admitted it uses VPN software to access Twitter, circumventing the will of the Chinese government.  Wonder if someone at Huawei should perhaps be docked a few months pay for that.  Maybe the CEO.  

christopher126 16 Years · 4366 comments

This may sound ethnocentric, but I'm glad I don't live in China and it is steadily moving down my list of places I'd like to visit.

Best