Roger Fingas
While it's likely to remain a distant second in terms of overall transactions, Apple Pay is poised to narrow the volume gap with rival platform PayPal in next few years, according to Morgan Stanley analysts.
Apple Pay transactions are forecast to reach $190 billion in 2022, and $304 billion by 2027, the firm said in a memo issued on Wednesday. That ranks against PayPal figures of $431 billion and $579 billion, respectively, though excluding any offline wallet possibilities, which could theoretically add as much as $257 billion to PayPal's volume by 2027.
While PayPal has "the best consumer penetration by far," Apple is "the clear leader among app/phone-based digital wallets, and has seen 300bps [basis points] of growth in online usage since summer 2018 survey," the memo continued.
"We expect the new Apple Card, launching this summer with Goldman Sachs and Mastercard and 2% cash back on Apple Pay purchases, will help drive up Apple Pay awareness and usage," the analysts added.
In a second memo Morgan Stanley positioned the Apple Card as a win-win for Apple and Goldman Sachs, the former by driving more people to Apple stores — where Apple reaps higher profits — as well as by increasing awareness of the Apple Wallet and Apple Pay, and boosting overall services revenue.
For Goldman Sachs the card is expected to aid a strategy towards "a more stable revenue source than trading revenues," and perhaps lure Apple Card customers into cross-selling opportunities, or at least raising brand visibility.
The two companies will likely change the card's reward structure within the first two years, the analysts said, because it could draw in "materially more card holders" who would spend more on Apple Pay and other services.
"We believe a rewards boost, such as to 5% at Apple Stores, 3% on Apple Pay, or inclusion of a new category such as dining, would significantly increase the card uptake and the EPS benefit," the second memo argued. "Apple could fund this reward boost from the higher margin generated by pulling 3rd party sales to its own retail and on-line stores."
The Apple Card is currently in testing ahead of a launch within the next few months. Though primarily digital, owners will also get a real-world titanium card for cases when Apple Pay isn't available.
Christine McKee
Andrew Orr
Charles Martin
Marko Zivkovic
Wesley Hilliard
19 Comments
Looking forward to Apple Card. I will likely never use the physical one, might not even carry it with me, as I get a better cash back deal with other physical cards. "This summer" means any time before mid-September. It wouldn't shock me if it was delayed further though. Its a big undertaking with some significant risk.
Apple Pay will never 'catch up' to Paypal and the rest in sheer volume and numbers... for one important reason: It is APPLE. And not everyone is a bonified Apple Sheep. Until (if ever) AP crosses over to the Mainstream financial markets... there will always be a finite amount of 'converted' or convertible individuals.
What I want is for Apple to make a big push into online utility payments. My Gas and Electric bills clear through some vulture outfit called Bill Matrix that takes a $2-3 drag just so you can use your debit or credit instead of handing them the keys to your checking account. Apple is finally available from Comcast for my ISP bill, but they need to go after that market.
As to credit cards:
I currently have a card that is 0.0% APR for 18 months and there will be another waiting when the teaser rate expires.
There is no way I would pay the usurious rates common to credit cards- especially to anything related to Goldman - for some cash back scheme. Tell them to keep the cash back and lower the interest rate. The rates Apple and Goldman will be charging used to be the kind available from loan sharks.