Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

New German law mandates opening up Apple Pay NFC tech to rivals

Last updated

German legislators have rushed new legislation through that could force Apple to provide access to its NFC chip, allowing competitors to provide their own mobile payment platforms on the iPhone and Apple Watch.

In a late-night session on Wednesday, a German parliamentary committee suddenly voted to pressure Apple into to offering Apple Pay to rival providers in Germany.

It came in the form of an amendment to an anti-money laundering law that was adopted late Thursday and is set to come into effect early next year. While the law didn't specifically name Apple, it would require any operator or an electronic money infrastructure to offer access to rivals at a reasonable fee.

The legislation reflects Germany's increasing willingness to loosen U.S. technology companies' control on technology products and services.

"We are surprised at how suddenly this legislation was introduced," Apple said of the matter. "We fear that the draft law could be harmful to user friendliness, data protection and the security of financial information."

A person close to the government coalition had told Reuters that Chancellor Angela Merkel's office had pushed for the committee to withdraw the amendment.

The Chancellor's move had raised concerns from Germany's Social Democratic Party.

"It's quite unusual for the Chancellor's office to try and stop something in the last minute," said Jens Zimmermann, a senior lawmaker from the Social Democrats (SPD), junior coalition partners to Merkel's conservatives.

"It would be astonishing if they let themselves be reined back by an American company," he added. "We want fair competition between payment providers."

Apple Pay has been rapidly expanding across the globe in the last few years. Germany first saw Apple Pay in December of 2018.

Apple has also been targeted by an anti-competitive investigation by the European Commission regarding the choice to limit the NFC chip to Apple Pay.



90 Comments

javacowboy 20 Years · 664 comments

I'm not American.

Still, I'm becoming increasingly frustrated by what I see as an egregious anti-American bias by various governments in the EU nowadays.

People who claim that Apple somehow has a "monopoly" are using specious logic.  Apple competes with numerous other platforms, each of which contains an ecosystem combining hardware and software.  Apple no more has a monopoly on its own software than Ford has a monopoly on the software running in its cars.

 

jimh2 8 Years · 670 comments

I'm not American.

Still, I'm becoming increasingly frustrated by what I see as an egregious anti-American bias by various governments in the EU nowadays.

People who claim that Apple somehow has a "monopoly" are using specious logic.  Apple competes with numerous other platforms, each of which contains an ecosystem combining hardware and software.  Apple no more has a monopoly on its own software than Ford has a monopoly on the software running in its cars.

 

The Apple ecosystem is a major contributing factor as to why people buy their products. They may have to capitulate on this nonsense, but it won't matter as it is highly unlikely anyone would use the alternative. In terms of market share versus Android they are the underdog. If you want to go after company start with Google who creates and maintains Android.

foregoneconclusion 12 Years · 2857 comments

Apple no more has a monopoly on its own software than Ford has a monopoly on the software running in its cars.

 

It doesn't matter that they're not a monopoly. Your business can be subject to regulation regardless.

StrangeDays 8 Years · 12986 comments

"It would be astonishing if they let themselves be reined back by an American company," he added. "We want fair competition between payment providers."

Fair competition would mean other providers building their own hardware to compete or partnering with other hardware providers to compete. Not forcing a non-majority device maker to implement their competing software. 

StrangeDays 8 Years · 12986 comments

Apple no more has a monopoly on its own software than Ford has a monopoly on the software running in its cars.
It doesn't matter that they're not a monopoly. Your business can be subject to regulation regardless. 

Of course. Regulation is whatever a society decides it is. But we’re discussing whether it’s logical and fair, as is the argument made.