Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

SFPD launches internal investigation over role in search for iPhone prototype

The San Francisco Police Department has initiated an internal investigation into the role some of its officers played in assisting Apple security officials in a search for a lost prototype of Apple's unreleased fifth-generation iPhone.

Lt. Troy Dangerfield revealed to CNet on Wednesday that an investigation is underway which may involve interviewing Sergio Calderón, the man whose house was searched by Apple employees.

Details emerged last week that Apple was on the hunt for a missing iPhone prototype that had been left in the Cava22 bar (pictured below) in San Francisco's Mission district in late July. Apple reportedly tracked the device to a residence in the Bernal Heights neighborhood and enlisted the help of the police to pay a visit to the house.

The SFPD originally claimed that it had no record of such an investigation, but then confirmed that "three or four" plainclothes officers had accompanied Apple security personnel to the house without going inside.

For his part, Calderón alleges that he was led to believe that the people searching his house were police officers. According to him, he would not have consented to the search had he known that they were Apple employees. The 22-year-old also noted that the officers had vaguely threatened him by questioning the immigration status of members of his household. He said that he is "talking to an attorney," but did not indicate whether he intends to formally press charges.

SFPD Chief Greg Suhr told the San Francisco Chronicle the police regularly assist independent private investigators. "The reason we do civil standby is to make sure there isn't a problem," he was reported as saying. "Whatever conversations the (Apple) employees had with the resident, I can't say."

As of earlier this month, Apple is shopping for two new managers of "New Product Security" to help prevent incidences like lost prototypes from reoccurring. The company is known for its tight security and has a variety of measures in place to protect itself from leaks.

However, in spite of its security protocols, Apple has now had two iPhone test device leaks in less than two years. Last year, an iPhone engineer lost an iPhone 4 prototype in a Redwood City, Calif., bar. The device was reportedly sold to Gawker Media for $5000. The two individuals who received payment for the prototype have been charged for "misappropriation of lost property.



62 Comments

eriamjh 18 Years · 1778 comments

This phone may be really lost. Why haven't pics of it come up on the internet? Maybe because it looks just like a regular iPhone 4?

suddenly newton 15 Years · 13819 comments

I don't understand what this person is alleging: that there deliberate deception or that he wasn't sure or misunderstood who was asking for his consent to search his home? I can understand how easy it might be for a bunch of guys to show up, and if no one is in uniform, you might think they were all from the same agency. Seriously, if they're not in uniform, ask to see a badge number.

neox360 18 Years · 9 comments

Perhaps Apple should screen the employees that they give their prototypes a little better? ;-) I mean both prototypes left in a Bar??

splash-reverse 15 Years · 648 comments

They did nothing wrong the way I see it, SFPD. They waited outside so there won't be any problems. That Calderon guy should have checked credentials. Whatever it is, it is Apple security team that need to be looked at and definitely them crocked test engineers. I'm pretty sure the phone was there initially but seeing this has happened before, it gets hot pretty quickly so must have been ushered out of the building pretty quickly and have been off grid since.

gatorguy 14 Years · 24642 comments

Quote:
Originally Posted by Splash-reverse

They did nothing wrong the way I see it, SFPD. They waited outside so there won't be any problems. That Calderon guy should have checked credentials. Whatever it is, it is Apple security team that need to be looked at and definitely them crocked test engineers. I'm pretty sure the phone was there initially but seeing this has happened before, it gets hot pretty quickly so must have been ushered out of the building pretty quickly and have been off grid since.

Since it's not clear exactly what the plainclothes did, there's no way for any of us to make any definitive judgement whether they did anything wrong or not.