When Apple first announced the addition of multi-touch to the iPod nano, some pundits were skeptical about the elimination of the click wheel and physical buttons for playback control.
Of course, Apple Chief Executive Steve Jobs was confident that users would love the new control scheme. "This is the biggest reinvention of the iPod nano since its debut in 2005, and we think users are going to love it," Jobs said in a press release announcing the update. "Replacing the click wheel with our Multi-Touch interface has enabled us to shrink the iPod nano into an amazingly small design that is instantly wearable with its built-in clip."
Though initial reviews of the sixth-generation iPod nano were generally positive, some reviewers criticized the need to look at the iPod nano's display to control playback.
A newly revealed patent application shows that Apple has already looked into the issue and could be planning the addition of 'no-look' touch gestures to the iPod nano and other multi-touch devices. The application describes several multi-touch gestures that could be used to control a device without looking at the screen, or, more radically, to control a device without a screen.
Specific gestures mentioned in the filing include a single tap to play or pause, a double tap to advance to the next item and a triple tap to return to the previous item. To fast forward, users would double tap and then hold, and to rewind, users would triple tap and hold. Volume would be controlled through clockwise and counter-clockwise circular motions.
While the patent application does not specifically reference the iPod nano, several figures accompanying the application depict the form factor and interface of the current-generation iPod nano. However, the images lack the hardware volume buttons of the latest iPod nano.
The application was filed on Jun. 25, 2009, over a year before the release of the multi-touch iPod nano, and published on Dec. 30, 2010. Duncan Kerr and Nick King are listed as the inventors.
A teardown of the sixth-generation iPod nano, which comes in several different colors and starts at $149, estimated the device's bill of materials at $43.
The latest nano was recently hacked, though the hacker was only able to access the device's plist files and remove an application, creating a blank space on the home screen.
18 Comments
Tapping is considered a no-look gesture? How about two-finger swipes in different directions? Circle motion for volume or track select regardless of what is on the screen?
Wait a minute. Isn't the whole control scheme of the remote headphones? And now they think this deserves a patent because it is tapping on the screen and not a typical button?
And you thought the people wanting money for double clicking on a screen were bad.
Is it a good idea to repeat the BOM "estimate"? That probably only serves to legitimize the figure and misconceptions around it.
Back when the click wheel was the in thing, it could be very easily controlled, volume, play, pause, skip, FF, RW, without looking at it, so I guess it's a leap forward to 2003 functionality in this respect.
This is what you give up when you go with all touch vs. tactile buttons. Apple may yet figure out a better blend of the two, but for now it's a bit of a kluge.
Me thinks the current Nano is a dud. Everytime I'm in the Apple Store or a BestBuy, there is absolutely no one looking at the Nano (or Shuffle for that matter)
Frankly, I think the problem with the Nano is it's simply too difficult to use brought on by it's new smaller form factor. It's too damn small! (you have to wonder at Jobs' comment about chiseling your finger tips to use a 7" tablet)
Why not just keep a narrow candy bar shape along with a touch screen display.
Usability would be greatly improved as one can hold it with one hand and making the necessary gestures with the thumb.