Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Class action lawsuit attacks Tidal over 'Life of Pablo' exclusivity

A lawsuit launched Monday accuses Tidal — along with rapper Kanye West, and Jay Z's Carter Enterprises — of intentionally misleading people about West's album "The Life of Pablo," which was initially marketed as an exclusive on the streaming service.

The firm behind the suit, Edelson PC, is pursuing the matter as a class action case, arguing that Tidal made the promise solely to save its business, by both harvesting personal data — such as credit card information — and causing a spike in traffic and subscribers. Within 10 days, Tidal subscriber figures rocketed from 1 million to 2.5 million, Edelson claims.

Tidal itself has said that "The Life of Pablo" was streamed over 250 million times in its first week.

The case was filed through a U.S. District Court in San Francisco, the Associated Press said, and suggests that Tidal may have made as much as $84 million from misleading claims.

The crux of the suit appears to be a February Twitter comment by West, one of Tidal's owners, in which he said that "Life of Pablo" would "never never never be on Apple," and would in fact stay a Tidal exclusive. By April 1, the entire album was available on Apple Music and Spotify, complete with updated tracks.

Exclusives are now one of the primary competitive weapons in music streaming, employed not just by Tidal but by Apple and Spotify. Apple, for instance, has used Taylor Swift's album 1989 to help lock in listeners.



23 Comments

radarthekat 12 Years · 3904 comments

Careful what you tell your customers.  You may be required to stand by your words. 

wonkothesane 12 Years · 1738 comments

It would appear that to certain people "never" is a timespan that lasts as long as it takes to say and then forget "only this one phone". 

jbdragon 10 Years · 2312 comments

Careful what you tell your customers.  You may be required to stand by your words. 

I wish it stayed exclusive!.  But in the end I guess he would rather make money then staying exclusive.  This lawsuit is just dumb. Cancel service, go somewhere else if you want. 

cali 10 Years · 3494 comments

Yeah I noticed the whole album was "on Apple" recently. I noticed this days after I subscribed to a free Tidal trial to hear the album. I should sue Tidal for tricking me.

Re: Taylor Swift 1989 exclusive
Bad comparison as this wasn't exclusive to Apple Music. You could still buy it elsewhere. Life of Pablo was supposed to be Tidal stream only.

In slightly unrelated news Lil Wayne, the face of Sammy's ads made a song where he trashes android.
poor Sammy never gets a break. XD