Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

With $231B in cash, Apple's $14.5B EU tax hit doesn't concern Wall Street

Last updated

While a $14.5 billion payment of back taxes could bankrupt many major corporations, it's pocket change for a company as cash flush as Apple. As a result, analysts surveyed by AppleInsider on Tuesday said they aren't concerned about the European Commission's decision, regardless of how an appeal ultimately plays out.

Apple will appeal the ruling, and CEO Tim Cook has expressed confidence that his company will win that appeal. But in the interim, market watchers mostly shrugged off the news —  shares were down less than one percent in morning trading.

"Ultimately, we think today's result should have a minimal impact on AAPL's EU operations" - Amit Daryanani, RBC Capital Markets

Gene Munster of Piper Jaffray noted that if Apple were to pay the back taxes in full, it would amount to 10 percent of the company's net cash balance, or about $2.65 per share. The firm maintained its "overweight" rating, and noted that investors are more focused on next week's anticipated "iPhone 7" unveiling.

Similarly, Rod Hall of J.P. Morgan declared the ruling "largely irrelevant" to Apple's stock price. He did caution that higher taxes going forward could have an impact, but if Apple were to pay the full $14.5 billion, it would have just a 2.5 percent negative impact on earnings.

Steven Milunovich of UBS estimated that taking the back taxes out of net cash would affect AAPL share price by as little as $3 to $5. He also noted that the appeal process will likely take many years —  IBM just concluded a 7-year dispute with Japanese tax authorities, for example.

Also weighing in on Tuesday was Amit Daryanani of RBC Capital Markets, who noted that even factoring in its debt, Apple still has some $150 billion in net cash on its balance sheet.

"Ultimately, we think today's result should have a minimal impact on AAPL's EU operations," Daryanani wrote in a note to investors.

The European Commission announced the amount of back taxes owed by Apple on Tuesday, the culmination of a years-long investigation. Both Apple and the country of Ireland have appealed the ruling.

In the European Union's view, Ireland granted "illegal tax benefits" to Apple. They calculated that the company's tax rates on European profits were 0.005 percent in 2014, and 1 percent in 2003.



66 Comments

anantksundaram 18 Years · 20391 comments

There is no freakin' "Irish tax hit", AI. Stupid headline. C'mon...

applesauce007 17 Years · 1703 comments

This tax is not enforceable.
The European Union is so clueless, it should be dissolved.
One good thing could come out of this.  Ireland could follow the UK out of the EU.

https://66.media.tumblr.com/3da2defc9d1f1b43a8c56381a9564916/tumblr_nqnzqcLSZh1sg3akro1_250.gif 

nhughes 15 Years · 768 comments

There is no freakin' "Irish tax hit", AI. Stupid headline. C'mon...

Please, describe this very complex and nuanced story in 92 characters or less for me. You can't please everyone.

anantksundaram 18 Years · 20391 comments

nhughes said:
There is no freakin' "Irish tax hit", AI. Stupid headline. C'mon...
Please, describe this very complex and nuanced story in 92 characters or less for me. You can't please everyone.

"EU tax ruling"?

"EU tax claim"?

"EU spat with Ireland over Apple taxes"?

"Tax ruling that Apple and Ireland claim is nuts"?

"EU ruling that Apple and Ireland will appeal"?

I could go on...

---
ADDED: PERHAPS YOU MEANT THE WHOLE HEADLINE, SO HERE GOES (CHARACTER COUNT WITH SPACES INCL.):

With $231B in cash, EU’s $14.5B Irish-Apple tax ruling doesn't concern Wall Street (82 characters)

With $231B in cash, EU’s $14.5B tax claim against Apple doesn't concern Wall Street (83 characters)

With $231B in cash, EU’s tax spat with Ireland over Apple taxes doesn't concern Wall Street (91 characters)


lkrupp 19 Years · 10521 comments

Meanwhile @BenLovejoy over at 9TO5Mac is scribbling editorial after editorial while pounding his chest about how he knew all long Apple would lose and why Apple’s and Ireland’s appeals will fail. He does admit one thing, however. Apple will not writing a check anytime soon. Of that you can be sure.