Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Mac owners unable to log in to Messages, FaceTime after OS X 10.11.4 El Capitan update

Messages error pop-up via Apple Support Communities member "traffsh0w."

Last updated

A number of Mac owners are experiencing issues with iMessage and FaceTime logins after upgrading to the latest version of OS X 10.11.4 El Capitan released Monday, with evidence suggesting a bug in the apps' account activation system.

Mac owners have taken to Apple's Support Communities forum to report (1, 2, 3, 4) an apparent Messages and FaceTime authentication issue in OS X 10.11.4 El Capitan that prevents users from using either service. AppleInsider has also received multiple reports detailing identical problems. OS X 10.11.4 was released on Monday with various feature additions and improvements.

The issue presents itself after installing the latest version of OS X, with most users reporting a pop-up error dialogues reading, "Could not sign in to iMessage" and "An error occurred during authentication." In other cases, the iMessage setup window seems to send user ID information to Apple's servers, but hangs without timing out.

Since iCloud logins appear unaffected by the bug, the problem might trace back to Apple's iMessage and FaceTime control services. Reports of multiple errors within a single household or business deployment suggest a faulty node might be impacting a geographical subset of users. Circumstantial evidence supports the theory of a server-side issue, as at least one Mac owner saw login trouble persist after downgrading to OS X 10.10 Yosemite.

The percentage of Macs affected by the issue is unknown, though reports are coming in from both users of older model hardware and customers who just purchased their computer.

As for an effective workaround, users have attempted generating app-specific passwords, toggling two-factor authentication on and off, reinstalling the update and performing fresh installs, but a reliable alternative has yet to be discovered.

Some forum members who contacted Apple Support said representatives are aware of the problem and note Apple engineers are working on a fix. AppleInsider reached out for clarification on the matter and will update this article when an answer is received.

El Capitan's login issues come one day after iPad owners reported difficulty installing iOS 9.3 on older hardware. As with Messages and FaceTime on Mac, the issue on iPad appears during the account activation stage. However, the iPad bug prevents iOS from installing altogether, leaving some tablets unusable unless a system restore is performed through iTunes.



28 Comments

pmz 15 Years · 3429 comments

Haven't seen this myself, but if such a burg is pervasive, how was this not discovered during testing?

happilyretired 9 Years · 17 comments

Oh, the good old days! When all "Things (Apple) just worked", which, I'm afraid, has become a "Thing" of the past.

lkrupp 19 Years · 10521 comments

Oh, the good old days! When all "Things (Apple) just worked", which, I'm afraid, has become a "Thing" of the past.

Not for me. I still live in the good old days. I have not been affected by a single one of these so-called bugs. I have an iMac 14,2 (late 2013), an iPhone 6, an Apple TV 4, and an Watch. All upgraded to the latest software from two days ago. All upgrades went perfectly without issues. All hardware and software is working fine as it did before the upgrades. There are NO issues. I think you live in a different world than the vast majority of users. 

robogobo 17 Years · 377 comments

Oh, the good old days! When all "Things (Apple) just worked", which, I'm afraid, has become a "Thing" of the past.

Those days never existed. Either you were affected by a bug back then, today or one day you will be.

aldux 8 Years · 1 comment

So happy to read this after wasting hours today on exactly this issue.  Downgraded my iMac to Yosemite, and back to El Cap, tried several Apple ID's, erased keychain entries, reset PRAM and many other crazy detailed failed attempts to connect iMessage and FaceTime.  Everything else works great, but sure hope the engineers fix the authentication issue.