Cingular and Apple may team on music download service
Cingular Wireless, the No. 1 U.S. wireless carrier, hopes to team with Apple next year when it launches a service that will let users download music on their mobile phone, a senior executive said on Thursday.
Earlier this month, Apple along with Motorola introduced a new mobile handset called ROKR, which is the first cell phone to offer music playback through an embedded version of iTunes. Cingular is the first service provider to carry the phone.
Details regarding how the service would be run were still being worked out, according to Reuters, but de la Vega did say that he hoped it could be done in partnership with Apple.
Asked about demand for the ROKR, de la Vega said the company was making sales, but noted that "it takes a little while to build."
In the two weeks it has been available, the ROKR has failed to impress reviewers, consumers or the media. Fortune columnist Peter Lewis even went as far as calling the ROKR a "STINKR."
In his review of the phone, Lewis, like others, speculates that Apple may have intentionally crippled the ROKR.
"Apple has a good thing going with the iPod, and perhaps it didn't care to see the ROKR get good enough to kill that action."
If Apple and Cingular expanded their partnership to cover the new service, it would almost certainly yield the first mobile version of Apple's iTunes Music Store, allowing Cingular customers to shop for music from their mobile phone.
27 Comments
This "report" completely flies in the face of this article from MacCentral, in which Steve Jobs apparently said the opposite:
?I?m not convinced that it will be successful,? said Jobs. ?The network providers will charge a lot to download music to a mobile ? maybe US$3.?
Jobs also reasoned that a computer would still be required even if a mobile user downloaded music directly onto their mobile phone.
?You will have to backup the music on your phone up using your PC,? said Jobs. ?If you lose a phone then you lose all your music. If you get a new phone you have to transfer it all. It?s not clear that buying music over the air makes economic sense.?
I'm thinking I'm going to believe MacCentral here. Sorry Kasper.
\
This "report" completely flies in the face of this article from MacCentral, in which Steve Jobs apparently said the opposite:
I'm thinking I'm going to believe MacCentral here. Sorry Kasper.
\
I'm not convinced with Job's reasoning in entirety. Yes, if you lose your phone without synching, you lose the music, but if you simply damaged the old phone, buy a new phone that reads the same memory card type, then you should be able to swap cards.
Personally, I don't "get" the mobile phone market. I understand the desirability of having mobile service, but the upscale stuff is weird to me. The amount of money carriers charge for backgrounds, ring tones, games and such is IMO absurd, and very often, they "expire" in 90-180 days.
I've had the ROCKR for about a week or so. The 100 song limitation isn't the problem...think about it, that's like the same as a 6 CD changer one might have in their car.
The problems are...
1) The camera sucks (VGA resolution with poor imaging and compression).
2) You can't play AAC files greater than 128kbps. This means that if you have higher bitrate AAC files, you have to select "convert to 128kbps AAC". The problem is that it will then convert *all* songs on the phone...even MP3s.
3) It's USB 1.1 and as such takes about 1 hour to transfer all the songs.
4) While you can make a iTunes song a ringtone, it's not an easy process (many people think you can't, but you can).
5) You can't do different ringtones for different callers.
6) The audio quality of the phone for music is rather poor. It does work great for phone calls on speaker phone, but for music the built in speakers suck, and the music isn't much better with headphones.
--EDIT-- I forgot to add 7) The phone not only doesn't charge when connected via USB, but you can't connect via USB *and* plug in the charger at the same time.
Originally I was going to return the phone, but I think I'll keep it and use it for podcasts.
I'm hoping that with enough protest, they will release a better phone soon.
I've had the ROCKR for about a week or so. The 100 song limitation isn't the problem...think about it, that's like the same as a 6 CD changer one might have in their car.
The problems are...
1) The camera sucks (VGA resolution with poor imaging and compression).
2) You can't play AAC files greater than 128kbps. This means that if you have higher bitrate AAC files, you have to select "convert to 128kbps AAC". The problem is that it will then convert *all* songs on the phone...even MP3s.
3) It's USB 1.1 and as such takes about 1 hour to transfer all the songs.
4) While you can make a iTunes song a ringtone, it's not an easy process (many people think you can't, but you can).
5) You can't do different ringtones for different callers.
6) The audio quality of the phone for music is rather poor. It does work great for phone calls on speaker phone, but for music the built in speakers suck, and the music isn't much better with headphones.
Originally I was going to return the phone, but I think I'll keep it and use it for podcasts.
I'm hoping that with enough protest, they will release a better phone soon.
Motorola phones are hardly anything special -what was everyone expecting? Yes your concerns are more valid than most because you take into account that 100 songs isn't bad (the phone isn't designed for those with iPods remember). BUT Motorola always lack basic features which is why I didn't get the V3 RAZR and got the S700i