Never miss an update Follow AppleInsider
Apple's iPhone sales tactics in Europe under antitrust investigation
By Neil Hughes
Monday, May 27, 2013, 05:19 am PT (08:19 am ET)
Documents obtained by the Financial Times show that the European Commission has begun looking into whether Apple's agreements with carriers are illegal. The commission has expressed concern that the deals could ensure Apple's rivals cannot secure better sales agreements.

The investigation reportedly began after the commission received "private complaints from mobile operators." The commission's investigation remains preliminary, and no formal charges have been brought against Apple.
The investigation was brought to light by questionnaires sent by the commission to mobile operators across Europe. The nine-page document reportedly inquires whether carriers are being forced to buy a minimum number of iPhones, or if they are restricted on how to use their marketing budgets.
The document also asks whether Apple enforces any clauses on subsidies for handsets that compete with the iPhone, and it quizzes operators on whether contractual restrictions prevent the iPhone 5 from accessing high-speed 4G networks in Europe. Carriers have until June 17 to reply to the questionnaire.
Previous European Union investigations of Apple have taken a closer look at the company's warranty practices and the iPad maker's e-book deals with publishers. But those inquiries have not led to formal antitrust lawsuits.
Unbeatable Deals from AppleInsider & Apple's Top Authorized Resellers
SAVE $170.00 - 4 Hours only: Use $70 coupons on all current 13" MacBooks and 15" MacBook Pros (Save $75-$200 instantly
SAVE $200.00 - $100-$200 off every 12" MacBook for a limited time
SAVE $208.02 - Free AppleCare & $30 discounts on all 27" iMacs with Retina 5K display (Late-2015 models), tax-free in 48 states
Today's Headlines
- Apple releases second public beta of iOS 9.2 with support for AT&T NumberSync
- Microsoft opens sign-ups for testing Cortana assistant app on iOS
- Apple Watch raises awareness of wearables as Pebble doubles its sales, CEO says
- Steve Jobs considered an 'Apple Car' in 2008, iPod creator remembers
- Apple's iOS 9 now installed on two out of three compatible devices
On Topic: iPhone
- Microsoft opens sign-ups for testing Cortana assistant app on iOS
- Apple's 'iPhone 7 Plus' expected to pack 3GB of RAM into 'A10' CPU in late 2016
- Apple to launch new metal 4-inch iPhone with A9 CPU in 2016, insider says
- Google finds serious flaws in Android code Samsung added to Galaxy S6 Edge
- Apple Pay gains 54 more US card issuers ahead of Canadian, Australian launches
Previous Comments View All
As long as they don't violate any laws...
Competing with your products instead of distribution clauses is the way to go.
Apple pretty much sets the contract from my understanding and if the carrier doesnt like it, they dont get the iPhone. It has already been made known that Sprint is losing money from carrying the iPhone because of the contract that Apple requires. For other carriers, they probably see it as, "If we dont have the iPhone, we will lose our customers to the competition who have been waiting for their contract to end so they can get the iPhone with someone else."
I don't see anything illegal in making a product that the market really really wants, then squeeze the balls on everyone who's trying to sell that product to extract maximum profit from it.
Yet legality away, Apple is a bitch when it comes to negotiation. Apple wants deals that are often favorable to them, at the expense of its partners. I wouldn't mind seeing Apple lower the bar a bit and make the phones available to more carriers to increase its customer base.
Apple pretty much sets the contract from my understanding and if the carrier doesnt like it, they dont get the iPhone. It has already been made known that Sprint is losing money from carrying the iPhone because of the contract that Apple requires. For other carriers, they probably see it as, "If we dont have the iPhone, we will lose our customers to the competition who have been waiting for their contract to end so they can get the iPhone with someone else."
Indeed. Apple way of dealing with the carriers is rotten to the bone. All the concerns in the investigation are valid. Bullying the carriers is a double edge sword, especially when youre products are on the decline.
Because of the big market share in the US, the US carriers have no choice to accept Apple terms. I have seen numerous times Verizon and AT&T CEO's on CNBC complaining about subsidies and how they would loved to get rid of them, mainly because of Apple way of doing business with them. If you are wondering why the carriers stores push anything but the iphone to the customers, its because they hate Apple.
Elsewhere in the world, lost of carriers are not offering the iphone because of unacceptable Apple terms. To a lot of internationnal carriers, Apple tiny market share in there countries make it difficult for Apple to strike deals because the carriers dont care if they dont offer the iphone. So on top of not having there products being distributed, Apple is getting an anti-trust lawsuit. If there is one country where an anti-trust lawsuit should be made, its the US.
This is one the reasons Apple absolutly must deliver a sub $300, so it can be sold unlock by lots of internationnal carriers. I hope Apple gets to his sense and stop bullying the people that sell there products.
Previous European Union investigations of Apple have taken a closer look at the company's warranty practices and the iPad maker's e-book deals with publishers. But those inquiries have not led to formal antitrust lawsuits.
'Nuff said.
Apple is a big target and gets investigated all the time. Big deal.
Actually, the warranty problem did trigger a lot of lawsuits in EU. The only reason those lawsuit were drop is because Apple made modifications to there warranties. They extended them to 2 years and made it clear AppleCare was only for the third year.
LOL. Another moronic post from our resident option-expert-turned-EU-commercial-law-expert.
Right, and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that under any valid system of belief.
Oh, SHUT UP. Tell me, what magical "right" do the carriers have to the iPhone? Huh? Why do they "deserve" it? Why should Apple bow to the wishes of those who WILL give their users a worse experience than Apple wants?
Does anyone know exactly what contract terms got the EU's attention and in what way those terms might be illegal??
Latest Apple Headlines
-
Apple releases second public beta of iOS 9.2 with support for AT&T NumberSync ~1 hour ago
-
Microsoft opens sign-ups for testing Cortana assistant app on iOS ~4 hours ago
-
Apple Watch raises awareness of wearables as Pebble doubles its sales, CEO says ~4 hours ago
-
Steve Jobs considered an 'Apple Car' in 2008, iPod creator remembers ~5 hours ago
-
Apple's iOS 9 now installed on two out of three compatible devices ~14 hours ago
- more...
![]() |
||
|---|---|---|
| Condition: | Flawless | Good |
| Sell your iPhone 6 to Gazelle for up to: | ||
| iPhone 6 128GB | $305.00 | $270.00 |
| iPhone 6 64GB | $295.00 | $265.00 |
| iPhone 6 16GB | $290.00 | $260.00 |
| Sell your iPhone 6 plus to Gazelle for up to: | ||
| iPhone 6+ 128GB | $335.00 | $300.00 |
| iPhone 6+ 64GB | $330.00 | $295.00 |
| iPhone 6+ 16GB | $325.00 | $290.00 |
| Sell your iPhone 5s to Gazelle for up to: | ||
| iPhone 5S 64GB | $160.00 | $135.00 |
| iPhone 5S 32GB | $155.00 | $130.00 |
| iPhone 5S 16GB | $150.00 | $125.00 |
| Click to see payouts on other iPhone models | ||
Offer Expires 10/15/15. Read all the details here. |
||
Latest Features
-
AppleInsider podcast talks AAPL earnings, Android switchers, iPad sales, Apple TV, Steve Jobs & more ~5 days ago
-
Wall Street relieved by Apple's strong guidance for holiday quarter ~7 days ago
-
Notes of interest from Apple's Q4 2015 conference call ~8 days ago
-
Week in review video: Steve Jobs movie flops, Steph Curry commercial, Apple vs. Pandora & more ~9 days ago
-
Video: Potential automotive "Phase 2" R&D site now going up next to Apple Campus 2 Spaceship Ring ~12 days ago
| 21" iMac 4Ks | Price | Save |
|---|---|---|
| 21" 3.1GHz/8GB/1TB | $1,399.00+ | $100.00 |
| 27" iMac 5Ks | Price | Save |
| 27" 3.3GHz/8GB/1TB/290X | $1,749.00+ | $250.00 |
| 27" 3.5GHz/8GB/1TB/290X | $2,023.99+ | $375.01 |
| 13" MacBook Pros | Price | Save |
| 13" 3.0GHz i5/8GB/512GB | $1,599.00+ | $400.00 |
| 15" MacBook Pros | Price | Save |
| 15" 2.5GHz/16GB/512/750 | $1,899.00+ | $600.00 |
| 15" 2.8GHz/16GB/1TB | $2,799.00+ | $400.00 |
| MacBook Airs | Price | Save |
| 13" 1.7GHz/8GB/512GB | $1,249.00+ | $500.00 |
| 12" MacBooks | Price | Save |
| Silver 1.2GHz/8GB/512GB | $1,479.99+ | $119.01 |
| Silver 1.2GHz/8GB/512GB | $1,499.00+ | $100.00 |
| Grey 1.3GHz/8GB/512GB | $1,549.00+ | $200.00 |
| Click here for dozens more configurations | ||
| + No sales tax collected on orders outside NY | ||
Active Forum Topics
-
Review: Fourth-gen Apple TV with Siri Remote and tvOS App Store
87
-
Apple throws support behind Houston equal rights initiative
75
-
Microsoft makes across-the-board downgrades to OneDrive storage options, ditches unlimited tiers
47
-
Plex app turns 4th-gen Apple TV into personal media server
44
-
Time Warner Cable to trial TV packages for Internet-only subscribers
38
- more...
Lowest Prices Anywhere!
| 13" MacBook Pros | Price | You Save |
|---|---|---|
| 13" 2.7GHz/8GB/128GB | $1,175.99* | $123.01 |
| 13" 2.7GHz/8GB/256GB | $1,371.99* | $130.00 |
| 13" 2.9GHz/8GB/512GB | $1,665.99* | $133.01 |
| 13" 2.9GHz/16GB/512GB | $1,895.32* | $103.68 |
| 13" 3.1GHz/16GB/512GB | $2,096.22* | $102.78 |
| 15" MacBook Pro | Price | You Save |
| 15" 2.2GHz/16GB/256GB | $1,812.99* | $186.01 |
| 15" 2.5GHz/16GB/512/370 | $2,292.22* | $206.78 |
| 15" 2.5GHz/16GB/1TB/370 | $2,841.02* | $157.98 |
| 15" 2.8GHz/16GB/512GB | $2,468.62* | $130.38 |
| 15" 2.8GHz/16GB/512/370 | $2,596.02* | $102.98 |
| 15" 2.8GHz/16GB/1TB/ | $2,958.62* | $140.38 |
* price with Promo Code:
APPLEINSIDER01
|
||
| prices.appleinsider.com for more configurations | ||
| * No tax outside CA, CO, GA, IL, MN, NC, NY, TN, & WI. | ||
Latest Exclusives
-
Killer Deals: Free AppleCare with each of Apple's new iMac 4Ks and iMac 5Ks ~2 days ago
-
-
Killer Deal: Fully-loaded 11" MacBook Air for $999 (or $1,089 with AppleCare plus 2 free accessories) ~15 days ago
-
Apple's 'Project Titan' car faces manufacturing roadblocks, could necessitate partnership ~2 months ago
-
Apple's 'Project Titan' car initiative negatively impacting Tesla's product development, source says ~2 months ago









Surely any manufacturer can set the terms of its own distribution agreement? If you don't like them don't sign up.