Affiliate Disclosure
If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Read our ethics policy.

Billionaire Mark Cuban says Apple deserves a 'standing ovation' for fighting FBI on encryption

Last updated

Apple did "exactly the right thing" by refusing a request from the U.S. government to create a backdoor to access a terrorist's locked iPhone, billionaire Mark Cuban wrote in response to the encryption controversy this week.

"Amen. A standing ovation," Cuban wrote on his personal blog, heaping praise upon Apple and its chief executive, Tim Cook, for refusing to comply with the FBI's order. In his view, if Apple were to comply, it would open the doors for countless situations in the future where the government could point to this case as a precedent.

"We must stand up for our rights to free speech and liberty." - Mark Cuban

"Every tool that protects our privacy and liberties against oppression, tyranny, madmen and worse can often be used to take those very precious rights from us," Cuban said. "But like we protect our 2nd Amendment Right, we must not let some of the negatives stand in the way of the positives. We must stand up for our rights to free speech and liberty."

Cuban believes American citizens should begin pushing their representatives to pass a law that limits the circumstances under which companies can be compelled to help the government break into a device. He proposed a series of four points that would justify such an instance:

  • That the incident in question be declared an Act of Terrorism, with casualties
  • That there is reason to believe the device was possessed by a participant in the incident
  • The device must have been on location for the incident
  • The terrorist who owned the device must be deceased

Cuban admitted that the subject is "not an easy topic," but he believes an open discussion should be had for America to decide how to protect its citizens while also protecting personal liberties and security.

The open letter from Cuban joins a number of other high-profile names who have sided with Apple in its opposition to the government. Facebook, Twitter, Google and Microsoft have also expressed support for Apple.

The controversy began Tuesday, when a U.S. magistrate judge ordered Apple to comply with FBI requests to help extract data from an iPhone owned by one of the shooters involved in the December terrorist attack in San Bernardino, Calif. The device in question is an iPhone 5c that was password protected by the gunman, and is set to erase a stored decryption key after ten unsuccessful login attempts.

Apple Chief Executive Tim Cook responded with his own letter on Wednesday, saying that the creation of a backdoor tool to access a locked iPhone could open the flood gates for future issues, rippling well beyond the investigation into the San Bernardino shooting. The terrorist attack resulted in 16 deaths and 24 injuries.

Apple has appealed the U.S. magistrate judge's ruling, and has until Feb. 26 to respond with a filing in court.



50 Comments

🌟
hmlongco 9 Years · 587 comments

Basically he applauds Apple for standing up to them and then with his "rules" pushes the door wide open against the very thing they're standing against. 

Once you open the door you open the door not only for the US government but every government under which Apple sells phones.

And today it's just "terrorists", but tomorrow it's terrorist and pedophiles, and the next day it's terrorist and pedophiles and drug dealers, and the day after that it's terrorist and pedophiles and drug dealers and suspected criminals, and then...

🕯️
robin huber 22 Years · 4026 comments

In this case the ends don't even come close to justifying the means. A few days worth of probably redundant and useless data. When a hydrogen bomb is hidden in NYC on a countdown timer with the kill switch hidden in an encrypted iPhone, the issue will have legs. 

🎅
tmay 11 Years · 6456 comments

hmlongco said:
Basically he applauds Apple for standing up to them and then with his "rules" pushes the door wide open against the very thing they're standing against. 

Once you open the door you open the door not only for the US government but every government under which Apple sells phones.

And today it's just "terrorists", but tomorrow it's terrorist and pedophiles, and the next day it's terrorist and pedophiles and drug dealers, and the day after that it's terrorist and pedophiles and drug dealers and suspected criminals, and then...

I'm guessing that you should throw that in The Shark Tank and let someone else decide.

Me, I think it's a giveaway to Authoritarianism, just a bit slower to make the FBI feel sad.

🌟
freerange 16 Years · 1597 comments

hmlongco said:
Basically he applauds Apple for standing up to them and then with his "rules" pushes the door wide open against the very thing they're standing against. 

Once you open the door you open the door not only for the US government but every government under which Apple sells phones.

And today it's just "terrorists", but tomorrow it's terrorist and pedophiles, and the next day it's terrorist and pedophiles and drug dealers, and the day after that it's terrorist and pedophiles and drug dealers and suspected criminals, and then...

Precisely! It would have been better for him to keep his mouth shut! But you left out the key .... And the next day it's tyrannies trying to oppress their people.